{"schema":"pubphys.bundle/1","record":{"author":{"account_ref":null,"orcid":null},"builds_on":[],"content_schema":"pubphys.content.revision/1","content_sha256":"388623de254eb157e91f5623dc6d87c25ad71f0d14b993c7a2a34aec395604a4","created":"2026-10-15T23:43:22Z","files":[],"origin":{"assisted_by":[],"kind":"seed"},"parents":["20533b0e83e6778a8547a5f7ebb3b815e42e6969f80fff7e3f6449d666011b2b","ce59fb6cd812fc05906d0c60a71c75ea22bc686bcf38e7c3ef7010834d98ee7b"],"salt":"15ad0ba08b6788425a3eb31db0c325a2aa5d83369d7199674894d2b26a7732a8","schema":"pubphys.record/2","site":"pubphys.com","target":null,"type":"revision"},"content":{"answer_type":"yes-no","assisted_by":[],"external_id":"plasma.edge-pedestal-elms.elm-free-reactor-regime","kind":"well-posed","literature_status":"open","n":"2","parents":[],"plain":"Several tokamak operating modes keep good confinement without large ELM bursts, but each has been found only under conditions that a reactor may not reach. Whether any of them survives at reactor density, low rotation and a cool divertor is unknown.","posed_since":"","precise":"Candidate regimes are QH-mode (edge harmonic oscillation), I-mode, EDA H-mode, small or grassy ELM regimes (quasi-continuous exhaust) and negative-triangularity L-mode edges. Determine whether at least one achieves $H_{98}$ near 1, no type-I ELMs and a detached divertor simultaneously at reactor-relevant $n_{e}/n_{G}$ of about 0.8 or more, low external torque, high separatrix density and pedestal collisionality as low as ITER $Q = 10$. An answer is a demonstrated discharge meeting all conditions on one device, or a validated stability analysis showing that each regime's access window excludes them.","problem_ref":"20533b0e83e6778a8547a5f7ebb3b815e42e6969f80fff7e3f6449d666011b2b","references":"","settled_by":"A steady discharge meeting all listed conditions simultaneously, together with a validated model of its access window extrapolated to ITER.","status_note":"","title":"Is any ELM-free or small-ELM regime compatible with reactor conditions?","topic_ref":null},"content_withheld":"false","files":[],"attested":{"attestation":{"batch":null,"client_id":null,"id_token_sha256":null,"kind":"platform"},"record_hash":"3eee2ff493f97da1ff663ed6abb5f34f2e7bdc3b775a7cb508793a2c83be5a89","schema":"pubphys.attested/1"},"id_token":null,"id_token_withheld":"false","envelope":{"attested_hash":"f5635a39c26b87b482fd19340bfd75682d4d1550cedd31d7302f12d8e35b3279","platform_signature":{"key_id":"c6afc19b31429869751f06879c75cd64ea92654423d15b44be775bf1310a60da","sig":"RPwdXEO6IAMwCjnRdDWTt52nAdDN2sIUnwBZGwPjCZrVDMRadMbcAa9gA5k2A0PFf14ZHBacU3Q8Vi0BUMDDCg"},"schema":"pubphys.envelope/1"},"ots":{"attested":["AE9wZW5UaW1lc3RhbXBzAABQcm9vZgC_ieLohOiSlAEI9WNaOcJrh7SC_Rk0C_11aC1NFVDO3THXMC8S2ONbMnnwIPWLI0BSkKAFAHDKieJlhJ7zFB9ZB-3M4hHrzCuWur7eCPAgaqvo0d6YuXzqt2AQV8hxof97kiH7IlsfYxBPYlJ2vpwI8SDqDrCTAMS9WhQ61HkloDk1khiPoKy2XXAitPZAnp1MowjxIDv5bpDfbzSAxt1qQCX5TkDzeDXpEw-oR-kLxKTlKfVACPAgNU1w7cKAplgTei9cfdKAtFwCJLm1bCwQIJ4BrPcfTUUI8SBT7Q-kliZbjcj0B93Wfmm0R72vVQSLHykUWw8pcZ577gjxIMMrFRsL2yt6eaedRrGpL3F7JOgq7Ux325nt-rbwOH2yCPAgdC7SAy2fK-S3eSva7tx7owCrlOOu0_v14gC5EshI7qAI8SBFZ7nkuh-5IaK75jNF2I3u9gWIJeTINL1f_rXWP5TwxwjxIK8CKI34eu_sgR6N3zB1SKGijO7ko6-mgEUnS-DdScYBCP_wCOf1iajMfCj1CPAQnjpoz1kO_dN22pXdltGw2AjxIE4XykgsZ_WSh2vkwqZCzoJ33eOitoafeDpQ-3_6R7A_CPAg4b6CYztt395HgCIMw1-W5LfG-vu-JwtH6wIGvmq0bZwI8CCtU0WsKh5BwLGGWacTQHMeBHwdClkCV-rMMMXN9ZvwZQjxBGrRZZPwCNknZwX9zuTwAIPf4w0u-QyOLCtodHRwczovL2JvYi5idGMuY2FsZW5kYXIub3BlbnRpbWVzdGFtcHMub3Jn8Aj1kxLXPF3sgQjwEN3TRaAlnRGdywLUXJqL_hoI8SC_EwWue7sXTkhbkg2KtpDc5URgyM3Hol8HHDVDiM8uLgjxBGrRZZLwCDbPE8C0jkmw_wCD3-MNLvkMji4taHR0cHM6Ly9hbGljZS5idGMuY2FsZW5kYXIub3BlbnRpbWVzdGFtcHMub3JnCPEgcCe_goUV_i6JgQUm8vGIzFLLPxWjAk_iuhN8MP2HtsgI8CCPm2C9s0XubFI_iMYYTrp7NQVEucjiDVVOS-5XhW0I8AjwILGVzUe4o5G4eCfsNghhwOFziij306RNYES910HKmhrsCPAgVyONoXyQM0NgJkZo0hKVGO9f4juKf5A3CyvglhBsUm8I8CCeXSTiCzsu5jmLW6aIc74nszLe4FOEslRZChj0t1VKtAjxIDr4W3XX8r8aow1ZiGRWxWoIW9dJhunhLwmguwsGdTO-CPEgELz-YATskE_flI3EMFwbuOgsnBRGkzF1Xa9I7rj-MQ4I8SB7TgKiPXFKLsITxTCqIEY2E_JnlB0P9hnCf6F5J05tTgjxIGB0NKCvdVTHWPyb-krv47MzDAWBd4vLje6N98K_6F_kCPAgyX4-cC3jGOgERVTj6eTI3Q0pFr0C9fiQQx-WUXIglL0I8VkBAAAAAfPitX67BAWDTZtWcQxQWCkh0YqMzi1a4gPWRNWeuOKwAAAAAAD-____AlREAgAAAAAAFgAUEXKzahzT5T5tisLdW6UYvM0Pl9sAAAAAAAAAACJqIPAEctMOAAgI8SAwkgFiLjrE4i4UPDMn2c7HXieBbkduCVR_rk5GmSghhwgI8CAeAZYQYIMdaCxzBP3Y06gnuz57Ns-TKJavZGdhkML93AgI8CC198zLIu74yxwmwNzR3PAaynBKuua9UCcw2CyBaEcKWAgI8CAxSXU58ENTCGnlVmMfBUDSe7PUXkdlNQkIcCczUvUXcwgI8CBK0rtRametS55XkRoTu4TTLoEsynoQA2atuGtOoQFm7wgI8CDktVbsge1QvmY068_HWE5N8syaqVDu30QVb4oO2shIhAgI8CAAGBdnq6kVTyqINAoW1AWmqSMrCXQ-zEzglSNUuUMpuQgI8CATBv3oWI6GOVvAjwYVlDhrkZfDGzhtR2pU4wqu0FZXfQgI8SCoGD7CnRzwIA9X2TonvAhr38a1B-laaGkTXOoVnKLalAgI8CDalktNU8YluuKLPRSEzK1gNVgBc6BCdYNysw57Ar07xwgI8SDGbdDDNu9PiyInO5tAadJPrtta_57FjBI8_UoOLsJpTAgI8SCbq51S51-NRozSBQVPKUoYMzKmPum0xMbTObF39PnJNwgI8CAyk4ieSMUJWnWk5mF9mfI8CXyF1YaYfNBysYuAvBIouAgIAAWIlg1z1xkBA_OmOw"],"envelope":["AE9wZW5UaW1lc3RhbXBzAABQcm9vZgC_ieLohOiSlAEI74pei_5-OxUhObmvHJ0lqF_4q8s_G6c0jCnvEMyXCrbwIO-U2QyHqSQbD_nijwj3wPnrG_K8L1HROJstyqlipXukCPAgGHg0mrsAMN9XSZpBatm1PWwRKILiGF3bHWa9PWBJ6ZYI8SAsdNmLkgwo6C7sNlA0w5etqFtYinIUONRaoZsvKCL8AwjxIA2hV1vTaHnZ0H1C8QPNCa4zPF28I1WTprq_7EMWTmgNCPAgTIi7pTyOUloYbDo8jyi045qjrPOAUq1m63KiIzQgnioI8SCsPaknvtpl8xqUSQ375WqVAyNnnaFHf5R0P7tfqwlu9wjwIMH_9aFK1xnp4BXFZuvdPeSXUB5AoGY62wnaRIKCKFSbCPAgdC7SAy2fK-S3eSva7tx7owCrlOOu0_v14gC5EshI7qAI8SBFZ7nkuh-5IaK75jNF2I3u9gWIJeTINL1f_rXWP5TwxwjxIK8CKI34eu_sgR6N3zB1SKGijO7ko6-mgEUnS-DdScYBCP_wCOf1iajMfCj1CPAQnjpoz1kO_dN22pXdltGw2AjxIE4XykgsZ_WSh2vkwqZCzoJ33eOitoafeDpQ-3_6R7A_CPAg4b6CYztt395HgCIMw1-W5LfG-vu-JwtH6wIGvmq0bZwI8CCtU0WsKh5BwLGGWacTQHMeBHwdClkCV-rMMMXN9ZvwZQjxBGrRZZPwCNknZwX9zuTwAIPf4w0u-QyOLCtodHRwczovL2JvYi5idGMuY2FsZW5kYXIub3BlbnRpbWVzdGFtcHMub3Jn8Aj1kxLXPF3sgQjwEN3TRaAlnRGdywLUXJqL_hoI8SC_EwWue7sXTkhbkg2KtpDc5URgyM3Hol8HHDVDiM8uLgjxBGrRZZLwCDbPE8C0jkmw_wCD3-MNLvkMji4taHR0cHM6Ly9hbGljZS5idGMuY2FsZW5kYXIub3BlbnRpbWVzdGFtcHMub3JnCPEgcCe_goUV_i6JgQUm8vGIzFLLPxWjAk_iuhN8MP2HtsgI8CCPm2C9s0XubFI_iMYYTrp7NQVEucjiDVVOS-5XhW0I8AjwILGVzUe4o5G4eCfsNghhwOFziij306RNYES910HKmhrsCPAgVyONoXyQM0NgJkZo0hKVGO9f4juKf5A3CyvglhBsUm8I8CCeXSTiCzsu5jmLW6aIc74nszLe4FOEslRZChj0t1VKtAjxIDr4W3XX8r8aow1ZiGRWxWoIW9dJhunhLwmguwsGdTO-CPEgELz-YATskE_flI3EMFwbuOgsnBRGkzF1Xa9I7rj-MQ4I8SB7TgKiPXFKLsITxTCqIEY2E_JnlB0P9hnCf6F5J05tTgjxIGB0NKCvdVTHWPyb-krv47MzDAWBd4vLje6N98K_6F_kCPAgyX4-cC3jGOgERVTj6eTI3Q0pFr0C9fiQQx-WUXIglL0I8VkBAAAAAfPitX67BAWDTZtWcQxQWCkh0YqMzi1a4gPWRNWeuOKwAAAAAAD-____AlREAgAAAAAAFgAUEXKzahzT5T5tisLdW6UYvM0Pl9sAAAAAAAAAACJqIPAEctMOAAgI8SAwkgFiLjrE4i4UPDMn2c7HXieBbkduCVR_rk5GmSghhwgI8CAeAZYQYIMdaCxzBP3Y06gnuz57Ns-TKJavZGdhkML93AgI8CC198zLIu74yxwmwNzR3PAaynBKuua9UCcw2CyBaEcKWAgI8CAxSXU58ENTCGnlVmMfBUDSe7PUXkdlNQkIcCczUvUXcwgI8CBK0rtRametS55XkRoTu4TTLoEsynoQA2atuGtOoQFm7wgI8CDktVbsge1QvmY068_HWE5N8syaqVDu30QVb4oO2shIhAgI8CAAGBdnq6kVTyqINAoW1AWmqSMrCXQ-zEzglSNUuUMpuQgI8CATBv3oWI6GOVvAjwYVlDhrkZfDGzhtR2pU4wqu0FZXfQgI8SCoGD7CnRzwIA9X2TonvAhr38a1B-laaGkTXOoVnKLalAgI8CDalktNU8YluuKLPRSEzK1gNVgBc6BCdYNysw57Ar07xwgI8SDGbdDDNu9PiyInO5tAadJPrtta_57FjBI8_UoOLsJpTAgI8SCbq51S51-NRozSBQVPKUoYMzKmPum0xMbTObF39PnJNwgI8CAyk4ieSMUJWnWk5mF9mfI8CXyF1YaYfNBysYuAvBIouAgIAAWIlg1z1xkBA_OmOw"]},"log":{"leaf_index":"3566","tree_size":"3804","proof":["3efbc459347ed4c86db660f1ec012cc3719eb2c3912dd645350062ace244381e","6524205490fea7949c49903391c608bca24e9161b55c6961b32d707782b6ec32","5ee588103cffe50b1023176a2db6ee02c2a78814db188d3f7fa643eaec9a1118","9341143cb5569ef5d3661418aaa0c85804d49243abcb020c45598a80cfc845bf","bf8c144e1bda09945ca3b4c1933835c6820461b948de9d235535ade2b50573b3","50d8a89e67ca2fa4fb7528dcf75cef50e44ea7069d21604cdb55ada73fb0ad71","266c6a520f7af5a577207d98d84af6d8d9ce15ca8b2ab64aa8d6617192db65df","32c308752f9217b1c4a86dd18bd7c428e4bf0819f03bcecd3c244aeb14e5c028","5bc8f1bbb7a36ffa2afc301ec767424419006f77d79dfc7ac3adb0dab9eb36e8","98b5a14b42b3a202b6ef825f66833fa505601404c4c0f14575f3ec922607a858","af34d80d0065c0ab502282775e865492e2cb49c9493f4594d63ba5577922854a","3c578dccc15502c5f3efe228cadc99fee76ab536ed01f66b14d316fdcc157429"],"checkpoint":"pubphys.com/log/v1\n3804\nAK6t4qgu96+M9wScTrIlsJ10d/zhKVEtYguyM3aeJvo=\n\n— pubphys.com/log/v1 JFPwIPP8EtoxgcsQg7V7CwIdL4UKPqJtpv+eB8sFNJjyQHIdyA1VabmBsPyLqq2bLxJPn57rA6fQi8y0QDDjRXHvlQg=\n","promise":"pubphys.com/log/v1 promise\n84fbdb99eaecd184bd3f3d24acb253a602699112df62d72f847e5fae1cd0d397\n3566\n2026-10-15T23:43:57Z\n2026-10-16T01:43:57Z\n\n— pubphys.com/log/v1 JFPwIMMNwHhiANHckIbNtlye+TW/JVf8WmyMEK0vNgyxfe9qW+WM3mfEkCpRJoueqIW2dmZPqDifls4S6xmWow+ksQc=\n"},"orcid_key_evidence":[],"attesting":null}