{"schema":"pubphys.bundle/1","record":{"author":{"account_ref":null,"orcid":null},"builds_on":[],"content_schema":"pubphys.content.revision/1","content_sha256":"bcce45d84e228d21cea501e8754c601320758652826a361faebd2098507ba9c2","created":"2026-10-03T07:18:03Z","files":[],"origin":{"assisted_by":[],"kind":"seed"},"parents":["5475cf5dc5b1a72283d26dc95dc6e00d7ea4e00096a7c6492e409a1816eeb011"],"salt":"8bf672cf64f54440e4be7c5d182fb0c3ceb50921d86db212bcdda721b3bc856b","schema":"pubphys.record/2","site":"pubphys.com","target":null,"type":"revision"},"content":{"answer_type":"yes-no","assisted_by":[],"external_id":"earth.venus-divergence.venus-water","kind":"well-posed","literature_status":"contested","n":"1","parents":[],"plain":"Venus's atmosphere has far more heavy hydrogen than Earth's, a sign that it once held more water that escaped to space. Whether that water was ever a liquid ocean or stayed as steam is unknown.","posed_since":"","precise":"The Venus atmospheric D/H ratio is about 100 to 150 times Earth's ocean value. Climate models allow a temperate surface to about 0.7 Ga if water condensed early, while other models keep water in a steam atmosphere that never condensed after the magma ocean. Determine whether liquid water existed on the surface and for how long. An answer is a measurement or decisive constraint (noble-gas and D/H profiles, tessera composition, interior water content).","problem_ref":null,"references":"","settled_by":"Descent-probe noble gas and isotope measurements plus orbital infrared mapping of tessera rock composition from planned Venus missions.","status_note":"A 2024 analysis of volcanic gas chemistry (arXiv:2412.01879) argued for a dry Venus interior, disfavoring a long ocean epoch.","title":"Did Venus ever have surface oceans?","topic_ref":"2d563ce4d5d56d2365b73e28ad4b61c690ba87ce44cf2790d484e63faf665432"},"content_withheld":"false","files":[],"attested":{"attestation":{"batch":null,"client_id":null,"id_token_sha256":null,"kind":"platform"},"record_hash":"d848dac570f00c18b6ff4df2c27348d655af6874bf9aa1ac57b7e826ef8febf7","schema":"pubphys.attested/1"},"id_token":null,"id_token_withheld":"false","envelope":{"attested_hash":"05775fe0627973fd471e5f29c6d2dbcb5df719623dfd226899e868d9c8abe01f","platform_signature":{"key_id":"c6afc19b31429869751f06879c75cd64ea92654423d15b44be775bf1310a60da","sig":"PEA5urd6pk0-21BjvknMVfdRuwlNsP1pGZA6wG03bnG8t9Y0yRAL7fX4oW69ZVTBiPWEQpq0xNuUvY9nDGXCDA"},"schema":"pubphys.envelope/1"},"ots":{"attested":["AE9wZW5UaW1lc3RhbXBzAABQcm9vZgC_ieLohOiSlAEIBXdf4GJ5c_1HHl8pxtLby133GWI9_SJomeho2cir4B_wIAV5Am7PyXJqCLMbBjOG5RNOIyrg5M1yHQoMY6nrNtyGCPEgcVA9Cj-mIi-BWyInmsDLICROP7BoN_xgbKgCn9lccq8I8CBT6G_6F5ImoF0suCWXljlm-vAzifAQIvdnOjNbnv3e4gjwICvpZoB0JP4Zd7q_MARh4eDXcvf0xPv2zt9mcWPgqFnaCPEgtA_x9BuD9KkwSn_AcJB87tvfw7HiOpb4-GkNkaCfbuwI8CDTjQ9L2DJ8_fBL1pwv-yzLF-GYobmUQaskz0LZNaQPXwjxICX4sWXZiUHn7v-zJ5hXalBcsa_hpGm08g9aBpaZojnECPAgNl1YNYfZwu98LlVobqGe3qyzw872nZef7-vqHE3nXn0I8CDTURm5psgkpndkZlRIia_PxrzHEbIi4fWR0w8YEe9YLAjwIMIc4xq7iJ2YP27EtWYUvEm4-TQD7cayDq2XvZh74n3BCPAg3v2QXfNkDO6Xzu9061umH0rhjRfHBKza3uG2nPQbpd8I8CCtNZgmApuKULvPC9nsMCaM05arV-F3o5FTlnJCnRvdMgjwIBGYo5Vxy-d7U5zKv5vp3Ii7hJPH_BDLCzA13c47p9q7CP_wCHbghVgOFMuNCPAQPZK2lHbTMqcCYUotzOQcmQjwIJ7ruRIs6HnufKxCpmLUgeUl0aUu0ov4_3PqcppS-bddCPEgI530vHzdwz_3o9jYQ3WablSaV64Wfn7Pmby5WLyI-A0I8QRqwKw78AhITF7Tr3a1xP8Ag9_jDS75DI4sK2h0dHBzOi8vYm9iLmJ0Yy5jYWxlbmRhci5vcGVudGltZXN0YW1wcy5vcmcI8CBXWeNiWFWltfHE0nkDXsVKIykUUwuObhsnN-2fvBt98gjwIM5Vf7j68sOFgVysYMc5S09Hho-fqxYW3oQ4oKUX7JpPCPAgaKHHQB3sdd9w1hu4NMh7vmb-p0X2r4uyVKKCj1G7S28I8SAW2Mg6Bzi9ygjrrjIYB7w90fwMcxH24SsqLmzPyAMGfwjwIMQ863zlveYIpNKWVrZaDOa4vowwoOg2CcTW8gXtxK3dCPEgrZxGGAf-t8jhz_eLMUyBN1IhNrdYDRcNHWvQcwNG9woI8CCVOUHG1YXudbaFIgUYvrCIevRWvb2ubhQAo-z0duD0rQjxIDBeKerVGkO3J2eXDwdraSioXbIWsdIPEN1s8pIwJIS2CPAgV2kB3n3JZ5HwBQjpRL1CWKnqvdCjZk3RcALk6N2wHigI8CB-wbljNlfqElD25uZkNg6taS81YDRU2vfMqGVQ420O9AjxWQEAAAABJM43UU6MLMRrPlCUqossvu1q_knons5yylyWTgxZzWUAAAAAAP7___8CLgABAAAAAAAWABQrYt3E7OllKRCEmL3FL589l78_5wAAAAAAAAAAImog8ATiyw4ACAjxILmbcIO7ixv3pCtwUMZ1VQGKus54F9lZ8-w5ECD5ZuiICAjwIG6ynCyFTLPE7Rgk-0ZGCtBDyqNQx8YvaSZNHy8D8p8jCAjwIMX8zoD2Be1YWvcx_bexVPRmBX0hK-do8b8t9SarimQVCAjxIG6XtpqIEclLlhzcK1LVjqoPGrjjmLnyno8tcETMzECECAjwIF6mlfXOFY51JhrK4eze8zQlKV75OYZYqbtyi8BWxmAsCAjwIKKUcJmVoz-u-geiRV_-ZHdF0VEPXaEPFWf_JX_0e7G2CAjxIGMeD0Z5QWNKBcAEpHht007FFIILW6aSJ8f3CMkKNsneCAjwIBFr6Je8rkB7kwhPGbq0yRgFwZsvW9JhY5sXDRtrq0QwCAjwIAHAwXaus-yUgKICJB5mVvx8VZuJgjwnpb0qWPg1pi6DCAjxIAJhb8cefkVHTAMymdsxa-_i-tUua62LcpALQnPG7R9_CAjwIDvsFqBhPfAL6TCtXZd7gBWmMpx6iiZ-Ug0Jf_LlcstgCAjwIDJRBX6Q0Vge-ra-k1_g76yJWTEp6WWF13I3JpTnsZPJCAjwILykZCbkC9VQgl5gytPKKir6T9nTvKR6y05iWSHBTQgzCAgABYiWDXPXGQED45c78Ah-sGbmQAwfZwjwEAYqxtHnZiPZnJEGPx_JvKsI8SDXkqDg17YsZIrEz5acRx7mBXCKW5mKNgRYnw_-U2cpDgjxBGrArDrwCEfK6Mono428_wCD3-MNLvkMji4taHR0cHM6Ly9hbGljZS5idGMuY2FsZW5kYXIub3BlbnRpbWVzdGFtcHMub3JnCPAg10nyJ6Jn4kshQQQCKE0Lvj3hBC6nLRBVIzaPV4eh8VwI8CCQaAqWlxEbac_XOq1MOlf9iOKHEsxXspzbjK0vLpy8BwjwII3iRbRXUcDxrhAdkZmFlI15nySCSEZ7g922tF1Xln5DCPEgYYvZ1L4v4rPu_UqLfcHPtwSb2OH2GhPgVcVhhH6DpkQI8CDZCIoR20sC-uchP40oAmcLm9EJFV7xzwplj54AeVadXQjxILvLBjPFpCoz29m9Yf2qRnV7PI9GqxE8ozVQfk9QwCqrCPEgZXcMudvEoB_MJ8tqOW2PLTKAIeQBnE-1bfzptRc2gR8I8VkBAAAAAfXq-bmxWqOz7B5wKkwjzHGv2R4s7Y0Z76LqXWYNhmz0AAAAAAD-____Av0cAAAAAAAAFgAUl-skmdZDtn7Hnub6mF4HP2uVn7oAAAAAAAAAACJqIPAE4MsOAAgI8CBDmQsbEXc46Hu8DivhCBM1LGExa4TTM-wo7HpoCVjBTQgI8CCty5vkQtPHzzs8xqArOYhVSjgaDoG1ou3cojv5_P7wQQgI8SDQWB0kdXCTwbk-TqTt0QfRMyzDNLOtU1XXFgvGSRlW8wgI8CC2PKa_QCIBZtrXodq1GdEzppISMsMRDOnzr2gFjLKOAAgI8CCwQ_QF67bcFk_uJ2s0VCZmf5PGIjTmTCpt_qnVY5p_8AgI8SAbzyx7z-oxPMju6PvtQhzrJIQyH2ZAc9oyLuYemzbmZQgI8CC5bh7J74uUk91r8LwybHQFCNBC3PWeuwtMCCNFKWj19AgI8SAf4R2TUNPjaX_PWDUImpoITK0JoW89zaMKnD1wlEEi8AgI8SC2vNmdm7eyP5Ytl1yTzT0njliMdALl1ViKG-s3bG2zswgI8CCpbIVNz1GFVXdJk2zd82hBUoNFFemUPBt7IJdWEOciPwgI8CBtYdRQcrtX1FtCm1SxF7sx-5cO04U8KzbJh8fqBkyReAgI8CBHs2LGmX6gI-lV7yp1RrV7_tGfdiBAwnEFF6B6yXHzAQgI8CATotVmbXBMAixhZ-QKy5Q4lR0FusdA_wcIC1TbB7GmxAgIAAWIlg1z1xkBA-KXOw"],"envelope":["AE9wZW5UaW1lc3RhbXBzAABQcm9vZgC_ieLohOiSlAEI-aq5KS0_w3dmrUFm-VRCtuNhEyK5x7zMkMSI4Dnpjh3xIPmqdVQQm2BG2v4C2WYEnTkvKOORAsBZZm59AJtrrCCFCPAg6WeG_-tE-knSC78XIZlbtXuQaMQmz1Hiju4vwI9sklkI8CCGkyQS1VjNtrxoBYpGLOXhnoGLr4AwhPOvgmDD1yS_yAjxIEaHTFEwHqXV2YvfbL86fC6H5cPNPeyD6e84L38PTXSlCPAgs6OLthZIM5_EKtMixiSvGAtcQwYn38ergXj3I5OkOJII8SAYagZTEwCVlMgXqQhOihWFZYtRA7vimmk7YupjYdRxTgjwII1OGo6m_8GpiiXK1pC7312jTWia9PNuWF9nWxoSLBVxCPAgwaB6v5-rgNtbRovqByHYFx5vLPaMlAE1dmQXdsyW6UQI8SDWlL7IzfO_cwYxfadaDmoPVp0tptPmw2XmYaU4JMe_wgj_8Ah24IVYDhTLjQjwED2StpR20zKnAmFKLczkHJkI8CCe67kSLOh57nysQqZi1IHlJdGlLtKL-P9z6nKaUvm3XQjxICOd9Lx83cM_96PY2EN1mm5UmleuFn5-z5m8uVi8iPgNCPEEasCsO_AISExe0692tcT_AIPf4w0u-QyOLCtodHRwczovL2JvYi5idGMuY2FsZW5kYXIub3BlbnRpbWVzdGFtcHMub3JnCPAgV1njYlhVpbXxxNJ5A17FSiMpFFMLjm4bJzftn7wbffII8CDOVX-4-vLDhYFcrGDHOUtPR4aPn6sWFt6EOKClF-yaTwjwIGihx0Ad7HXfcNYbuDTIe75m_qdF9q-LslSigo9Ru0tvCPEgFtjIOgc4vcoI664yGAe8PdH8DHMR9uErKi5sz8gDBn8I8CDEPOt85b3mCKTSlla2WgzmuL6MMKDoNgnE1vIF7cSt3QjxIK2cRhgH_rfI4c_3izFMgTdSITa3WA0XDR1r0HMDRvcKCPAglTlBxtWF7nW2hSIFGL6wiHr0Vr29rm4UAKPs9Hbg9K0I8SAwXinq1RpDtydnlw8Ha2koqF2yFrHSDxDdbPKSMCSEtgjwIFdpAd59yWeR8AUI6US9Qlip6r3Qo2ZN0XAC5OjdsB4oCPAgfsG5YzZX6hJQ9ubmZDYOrWkvNWA0VNr3zKhlUONtDvQI8VkBAAAAASTON1FOjCzEaz5QlKqLLL7tav5J6J7Ocspclk4MWc1lAAAAAAD-____Ai4AAQAAAAAAFgAUK2LdxOzpZSkQhJi9xS-fPZe_P-cAAAAAAAAAACJqIPAE4ssOAAgI8SC5m3CDu4sb96QrcFDGdVUBirrOeBfZWfPsORAg-WboiAgI8CBuspwshUyzxO0YJPtGRgrQQ8qjUMfGL2kmTR8vA_KfIwgI8CDF_M6A9gXtWFr3Mf23sVT0ZgV9ISvnaPG_LfUmq4pkFQgI8SBul7aaiBHJS5Yc3CtS1Y6qDxq445i58p6PLXBEzMxAhAgI8CBeppX1zhWOdSYayuHs3vM0JSle-TmGWKm7covAVsZgLAgI8CCilHCZlaM_rvoHokVf_mR3RdFRD12hDxVn_yV_9HuxtggI8SBjHg9GeUFjSgXABKR4bdNOxRSCC1umkifH9wjJCjbJ3ggI8CARa-iXvK5Ae5MITxm6tMkYBcGbL1vSYWObFw0ba6tEMAgI8CABwMF2rrPslICiAiQeZlb8fFWbiYI8J6W9Klj4NaYugwgI8SACYW_HHn5FR0wDMpnbMWvv4vrVLmuti3KQC0Jzxu0ffwgI8CA77BagYT3wC-kwrV2Xe4AVpjKceoomflINCX_y5XLLYAgI8CAyUQV-kNFYHvq2vpNf4O-siVkxKellhddyNyaU57GTyQgI8CC8pGQm5AvVUIJeYMrTyioq-k_Z07ykestOYlkhwU0IMwgIAAWIlg1z1xkBA-OXO_AIfrBm5kAMH2cI8BAGKsbR52Yj2ZyRBj8fybyrCPEg15Kg4Ne2LGSKxM-WnEce5gVwiluZijYEWJ8P_lNnKQ4I8QRqwKw68AhHyujKJ6ONvP8Ag9_jDS75DI4uLWh0dHBzOi8vYWxpY2UuYnRjLmNhbGVuZGFyLm9wZW50aW1lc3RhbXBzLm9yZwjwINdJ8ieiZ-JLIUEEAihNC7494QQupy0QVSM2j1eHofFcCPAgkGgKlpcRG2nP1zqtTDpX_YjihxLMV7Kc24ytLy6cvAcI8CCN4kW0V1HA8a4QHZGZhZSNeZ8kgkhGe4PdtrRdV5Z-QwjxIGGL2dS-L-Kz7v1Ki33Bz7cEm9jh9hoT4FXFYYR-g6ZECPAg2QiKEdtLAvrnIT-NKAJnC5vRCRVe8c8KZY-eAHlWnV0I8SC7ywYzxaQqM9vZvWH9qkZ1ezyPRqsRPKM1UH5PUMAqqwjxIGV3DLnbxKAfzCfLajltjy0ygCHkAZxPtW386bUXNoEfCPFZAQAAAAH16vm5sVqjs-wecCpMI8xxr9keLO2NGe-i6l1mDYZs9AAAAAAA_v___wL9HAAAAAAAABYAFJfrJJnWQ7Z-x57m-pheBz9rlZ-6AAAAAAAAAAAiaiDwBODLDgAICPAgQ5kLGxF3OOh7vA4r4QgTNSxhMWuE0zPsKOx6aAlYwU0ICPAgrcub5ELTx887PMagKzmIVUo4Gg6BtaLt3KI7-fz-8EEICPEg0FgdJHVwk8G5Pk6k7dEH0TMswzSzrVNV1xYLxkkZVvMICPAgtjymv0AiAWba16HatRnRM6aSEjLDEQzp869oBYyyjgAICPAgsEP0Beu23BZP7idrNFQmZn-TxiI05kwqbf6p1WOaf_AICPEgG88se8_qMTzI7uj77UIc6ySEMh9mQHPaMi7mHps25mUICPAguW4eye-LlJPda_C8Mmx0BQjQQtz1nrsLTAgjRSlo9fQICPEgH-Edk1DT42l_z1g1CJqaCEytCaFvPc2jCpw9cJRBIvAICPEgtrzZnZu3sj-WLZdck809J45YjHQC5dVYihvrN2xts7MICPAgqWyFTc9RhVV3SZNs3fNoQVKDRRXplDwbeyCXVhDnIj8ICPAgbWHUUHK7V9RbQptUsRe7MfuXDtOFPCs2yYfH6gZMkXgICPAgR7Nixpl-oCPpVe8qdUa1e_7Rn3YgQMJxBRegeslx8wEICPAgE6LVZm1wTAIsYWfkCsuUOJUdBbrHQP8HCAtU2wexpsQICAAFiJYNc9cZAQPilzs"]},"log":{"leaf_index":"1383","tree_size":"2123","proof":["59e3835b4e7fdcad03c5709bac84162eb7c0033e06e3227d47af5f9eb414b6e2","8676bc53e26b13c2c145b4df65085ce328dee07ed9507961f96972064ec41b64","ece1dd3b697edbd77eb0641dee432704894e9bab3bb13a1a38f6ce6ea4e45558","d022552c9f06586ed1d9697ef39c0ba23b239e281d2a9d4d97752d599fa131df","4c36650b27242f6b4fa23010f381d4e80b72e0a8aed6da055208744253c15bd9","b5a24e98eba2db386a40ea7631db3ee10ef714531d47aaf3ef0e574e4f2de794","fd309f7d3ed3c2642d045ee6d8ed8860eba54fc1955b15195a8510f3d7d9ef41","98160a74f0c064a3ca4a80464f21c444233b720409364e2b2bc71ff3c684846c","1dfea13acc3bebe31dadf39f646a423842e5bda8ab6493677ce2c28c00308b40","46022fbfd43c5aec3acbe84cb58891547da533c0320c5435c86490a040251104","2b97406e15e4d451a5450b3b53b677749fe0fa759579146dbfa1544c1e61a0ed","addcf2e0ff7974e4aa99af5e30d409f90d9f4311a4d85f5baf3e125eeb45b4c1"],"checkpoint":"pubphys.com/log/v1\n2123\npXVcluz7BF4vgChQs6lShuU0386gCH0RxrC1sxyE3rI=\n\n— pubphys.com/log/v1 JFPwIOLzsUD22XoTVyTfk/FMVj/u3f3DxZk4V/Ws10KVSS+8WQSwhunQ//EAhyS9Td5CyM0E++85GMezmKd8240j9Q8=\n","promise":null},"orcid_key_evidence":[],"attesting":null}