Are early black holes too massive for their host galaxies?

55

No. 473 in all physics · No. 47 in Astrophysics

Non-expert version

For broad-line AGN at $z > 4$, including little red dots, determine whether $M_{\mathrm{BH}}/M_{*}$ exceeds the local value $\sim 10^{-3}$ by factors 10-100 as single-epoch virial estimates ($M_{\mathrm{BH}}$ from FWHM of $\mathrm{H}-\alpha$ or $\mathrm{H}-\beta$ and luminosity) imply, or whether electron scattering and radiative transfer in dense gas broaden the lines and inflate $M_{\mathrm{BH}}$. The answer is a calibrated $M_{\mathrm{BH}}-M_{*}$ relation at $z > 4$ with $M_{\mathrm{BH}}$ measured independently of the virial line-width method.

What would settle it

Spatially resolved stellar or gas dynamics (JWST, ALMA, ELT-class telescopes) or reverberation mapping of $z > 4$ broad-line AGN, compared with virial estimates for the same objects.

Status in the literature

Unverified note: it names recent work and was partly written without a live literature search; it awaits a check by an editor.

Rusakov et al. (Nature, 2026, arXiv:2503.16595) argued that electron scattering in dense ionized cocoons broadens the lines, giving $M_{\mathrm{BH}} \sim 10^{5}-10^{7} M_{\mathrm{sun}}$, about 100 times below virial estimates; this is disputed.

No solutions, ideas or subproblems yet.

How results are checked

See also

Comments (0)

Comments are not records: they are not signed, stamped or logged. How comments work

No comments yet.

Sign in to comment.

Details, signature and history
Kind
Well-posed question
Answer
Yes no
Posed
2023
Topic review
K. Inayoshi, E. Visbal, Z. Haiman, The Assembly of the First Massive Black Holes, Annual Review of Astronomy and Astrophysics, 2020. Link
Record
Revision 2 · notation repaired by the platform · compiled by AI, not yet reviewed by an editor
Batch approval
Approved for the batch by Victor Galitski (ORCID 0000-0001-5532-1096) · approval record · bundle This approves the batch, not each problem (what it means).
AI systems
AI systems used to prepare this seed revision, as listed in its record: ai:gpt-5.5 (how the seed revision was made)
Earlier revisions
revision 1 bundle

Proof

Fingerprint
fef4b252886f…
Public log
Entry 531, in checkpoint 2,123
In the log by
Block 969,698, 2026-10-03

This text was in the PubPhys log by that date. The date says nothing about when the problem was first posed.

History