Why simulated and measured hard-sphere nucleation rates disagree

57

No. 403 in all physics · No. 28 in Soft Matter and Biological Physics

Non-expert version

For hard-sphere colloids at volume fractions $\phi$ of roughly $0.50\text{ to }0.53$, simulated nucleation rate densities (umbrella sampling, forward flux, brute-force MD) fall below light-scattering and microscopy measurements by roughly 10 or more orders of magnitude (up to 22 in some estimates), while agreeing at higher $\phi$. Identify the cause (polydispersity, sedimentation, solvent hydrodynamics, errors in mapping experimental to effective volume fraction, simulation method, or a deficiency in the nucleation picture itself) and reconcile simulation and experiment within statistical error.

What would settle it

Simulations and experiments on the same characterized system (polydispersity, gravity, effective $\phi$) giving rates that agree within error at low supersaturation.

Status in the literature

Unverified note: it names recent work and was partly written without a live literature search; it awaits a check by an editor.

A 2025 particle-level experiment (Kale, Lederer, Schoepe, Soft Matter 2025, https://doi.org/10.1039/D5SM00776C) argues that the gap requires a revised picture of nucleation rather than a correction to simulations; no reconciliation is accepted as of 2026.

No solutions, ideas or subproblems yet.

How results are checked

See also

Comments (0)

Comments are not records: they are not signed, stamped or logged. How comments work

No comments yet.

Sign in to comment.

Details, signature and history
Kind
Phenomenon to explain
Answer
Identification
Topic review
G. C. Sosso, J. Chen, S. J. Cox, et al., Crystal nucleation in liquids: Open questions and future challenges in molecular dynamics simulations, Chemical Reviews, 2016. Link
Record
Revision 1 · imported from the seed collection · compiled by AI, not yet reviewed by an editor

Proof

Fingerprint
6bcaa10eb565…
Public log
Entry 809, in checkpoint 2,123
In the log by
Block 969,698, 2026-10-03

This text was in the PubPhys log by that date. The date says nothing about when the problem was first posed.

History