Why simulated and measured hard-sphere nucleation rates disagree
57No. 403 in all physics · No. 28 in Soft Matter and Biological Physics
For hard-sphere colloids at volume fractions $\phi$ of roughly $0.50\text{ to }0.53$, simulated nucleation rate densities (umbrella sampling, forward flux, brute-force MD) fall below light-scattering and microscopy measurements by roughly 10 or more orders of magnitude (up to 22 in some estimates), while agreeing at higher $\phi$. Identify the cause (polydispersity, sedimentation, solvent hydrodynamics, errors in mapping experimental to effective volume fraction, simulation method, or a deficiency in the nucleation picture itself) and reconcile simulation and experiment within statistical error.
What would settle it
Simulations and experiments on the same characterized system (polydispersity, gravity, effective $\phi$) giving rates that agree within error at low supersaturation.
Status in the literature
Unverified note: it names recent work and was partly written without a live literature search; it awaits a check by an editor.
A 2025 particle-level experiment (Kale, Lederer, Schoepe, Soft Matter 2025, https://doi.org/10.1039/D5SM00776C) argues that the gap requires a revised picture of nucleation rather than a correction to simulations; no reconciliation is accepted as of 2026.
No solutions, ideas or subproblems yet.
See also
Details, signature and history
- Kind
- Phenomenon to explain
- Answer
- Identification
- Topic review
- G. C. Sosso, J. Chen, S. J. Cox, et al., Crystal nucleation in liquids: Open questions and future challenges in molecular dynamics simulations, Chemical Reviews, 2016. Link
- Record
- Revision 1 · imported from the seed collection · compiled by AI, not yet reviewed by an editor
Proof
- Fingerprint
- 6bcaa10eb565…
- Public log
- Entry 809, in checkpoint 2,123
- In the log by
- Block 969,698, 2026-10-03
This text was in the PubPhys log by that date. The date says nothing about when the problem was first posed.
Comments (0)
Comments are not records: they are not signed, stamped or logged. How comments work
No comments yet.
Sign in to comment.