Are thin co-orbiting planes of satellite galaxies consistent with cold dark matter?

40

No. 1,167 in all physics · No. 60 in Cosmology

Non-expert version

The Milky Way Vast Polar Structure and the Andromeda satellite plane contain a large fraction of each host's satellites in thin, partly co-orbiting configurations, which earlier analyses found in under about 1 percent of LCDM host analogs (moderate confidence). Determine, using Gaia and HST proper motions and orbit integration in realistic potentials, whether these planes are long-lived or transient, and the frequency of equally thin and co-orbiting planes in LCDM hydrodynamic simulations with matched selection, using a statistic fixed in advance.

What would settle it

Orbit integration with full 3D satellite velocities plus a pre-registered comparison against large hydrodynamic simulation suites of Milky Way and Andromeda analogs.

Status in the literature

Unverified note: it names recent work and was partly written without a live literature search; it awaits a check by an editor.

Sawala et al. (2023) found the Milky Way plane transient and consistent with LCDM, and Sawala (2025, arXiv:2510.01318) argues individual planes are short-lived while their orientation persists; the Andromeda plane remains debated.

No solutions, ideas or subproblems yet.

How results are checked

See also

Comments (0)

Comments are not records: they are not signed, stamped or logged. How comments work

No comments yet.

Sign in to comment.

Details, signature and history
Kind
Well-posed question
Answer
Value
Posed
2005
Topic review
Bullock J.S., Boylan-Kolchin M., Small-Scale Challenges to the LCDM Paradigm, Annual Review of Astronomy and Astrophysics, 2017. Link
Record
Revision 1 · imported from the seed collection · compiled by AI, not yet reviewed by an editor

Proof

Fingerprint
6e73fc29a48d…
Public log
Entry 1,252, in checkpoint 2,123
In the log by
Block 969,698, 2026-10-03

This text was in the PubPhys log by that date. The date says nothing about when the problem was first posed.

History