Do entanglement islands exist for evaporating black holes in ordinary 4D gravity?

60

No. 325 in all physics · No. 11 in Gravitation and Quantum Gravity

Non-expert version

Consider a 4D asymptotically flat Schwarzschild black hole evaporating to null infinity, with dynamical massless gravity everywhere and no non-gravitating bath. Does the prescription S(R) = min ext_I [A(boundary of I) c^3/(4 G hbar) + S_bulk(R u I)] with a nontrivial island I give a well-defined, gauge-invariant entropy for a radiation region R that follows the Page curve? Answer yes with a construction of R and I compatible with the gravitational Gauss law, or no with a proof that islands require a massive graviton or a non-gravitating region.

What would settle it

A gauge-invariant definition of the radiation algebra at null infinity together with a computation of its entropy, or a no-go theorem from the gravitational constraints.

Status in the literature

Unverified note: it names recent work and was partly written without a live literature search; it awaits a check by an editor.

Arguments that islands require massive gravity (Geng and Karch 2020, extended 2025) and defenses of islands in massless gravity (2025) both stand as of 2026.

No solutions, ideas or subproblems yet.

How results are checked

See also

Comments (0)

Comments are not records: they are not signed, stamped or logged. How comments work

No comments yet.

Sign in to comment.

Details, signature and history
Kind
Well-posed question
Answer
Yes no
Posed
2020
Topic review
A. Almheiri, T. Hartman, J. Maldacena, E. Shaghoulian, A. Tajdini, The entropy of Hawking radiation, Rev. Mod. Phys. 93, 035002, 2021. Link
Record
Revision 1 · imported from the seed collection · compiled by AI, not yet reviewed by an editor

Proof

Fingerprint
af58776fedfd…
Public log
Entry 1,465, in checkpoint 2,123
In the log by
Block 969,698, 2026-10-03

This text was in the PubPhys log by that date. The date says nothing about when the problem was first posed.

History