This browser is older than PubPhys supports. Every page can be read, but signing in to contribute, voting and signing need Safari 15.4, Chrome or Edge 99, Firefox 97 or newer. Browsers
All problems
57 problems
Starting order drafted by AI. Votes change it. How ranking works
-
For NaCl in water at 298 K and ambient pressure, compute from a molecular model not fitted to these data the solubility (measured about 6.15 mol/kg) and the mean ionic activity coefficient $\gamma_{+-}(m)$ from 0.1 mol/kg to saturation within 5 percent, including the chemical potential of the crystal. An answer is a model and free-energy method meeting these targets that transfers to LiCl, KCl and $\mathrm{CaCl_2}$ without refitting.
-
Is the neat water surface acidic or basic?
Contested 52For the interface of neat water (no surfactant impurities, pH 7, 300 K) with air or a hydrophobic liquid, determine the surface excess of H3O+ and OH- and the origin of the measured negative zeta potential (about -$2 \times 10^{-4}$ statvolt at neutral pH for bubbles and oil drops), choosing between OH- adsorption, interfacial charge transfer between water molecules, and impurity effects. An answer is a quantitative account in which spectroscopic, electrokinetic and simulation results agree.
-
For an excess proton in liquid water at $300\,\mathrm{K}$, identify the rate-limiting step of structural (Grotthuss) diffusion, the relay of the proton from molecule to molecule: hydrogen-bond breaking or forming in the second solvation shell, or motion along the proton-transfer coordinate. An answer is a simulation with path-integral nuclei on a near-quantum-chemical potential that reproduces the measured proton diffusion coefficient (about $9.3 \times 10^{-5}\,\mathrm{cm}^2/\mathrm{s}$) and its H/D isotope effect and identifies the step from the trajectories.
-
For liquid water at 300 K on a given potential of ab initio quality, compute the Kubo-transformed velocity and dipole time-correlation functions, hence the diffusion coefficient and the infrared spectrum including the O-H stretch band near 3400 $\mathrm{cm}^{-1}$, with errors relative to exact quantum dynamics smaller than the spread among centroid MD, RPMD, Matsubara-based and semiclassical methods. An answer is a systematically improvable method with polynomial cost in particle number, or a proof that such cost is impossible for generic anharmonic potentials.
-
Size and sign of inverted singlet-triplet gaps in heptazine molecules
Partially resolved 48For heptazine and a series of substituted derivatives, determine the adiabatic gap $\Delta_{\mathrm{ST}}=E(\mathrm{S1})-E(\mathrm{T1})$ to 0.05 eV, its sign across the series, and which electronic-structure ingredient (double excitations, spin polarization, dynamic correlation) is necessary to get the sign right. An answer is near-exact gaps for the series validated against measured delayed fluorescence and reverse intersystem crossing rates, with a design rule for negative $\Delta_{\mathrm{ST}}$.
-
For a medium-size organic molecule (for example phenylalanine or a substituted benzene) ionized by an attosecond XUV pulse, compute and measure the decay time $\tau_{coh}$ of the hole-density coherence between the lowest cationic states as nuclear motion and nuclear wavepacket spread are included. The answer is $\tau_{coh}$ with its dependence on molecular size and the number of active vibrational modes.
-
For water microdroplets of radius 1 to 20 micrometers produced by spraying or condensation in an oxygen-free and ozone-free atmosphere, determine whether $\mathrm{H_2O_2}$ forms at concentrations above 1 micromolar from water oxidation at the interface. An answer is a yes or no from controlled experiments that exclude dissolved oxygen, ozone, electrode and solid-contact sources, together with the energy source if yes.
-
For an excess proton in liquid water at $300\,\mathrm{K}$, determine the distribution of its solvation structures (Eigen H9O4+, Zundel H5O2+ and intermediates) including nuclear quantum effects, and assign the broad infrared continuum and the ultrafast 2D-IR signatures to these structures. An answer is a simulation at near-quantum-chemical accuracy with path-integral nuclei that reproduces the linear and 2D-IR spectra and gives the structure distribution.
-
Room-temperature strong coupling and chemistry of single molecules
Partially resolved 44In plasmonic nanocavities (gap below 1 nm) at 300 K, establish whether a single molecule reaches strong coupling, meaning a Rabi splitting 2g exceeding the mean of the plasmon and emitter linewidths with clear single-emitter evidence such as photon antibunching or a splitting that does not scale with molecule number, first for an electronic transition and then for a vibrational transition. Then determine whether single-molecule strong coupling changes a measured photochemical or thermal reaction rate of that molecule.
-
For a two-terminal junction of a chiral molecule, time-reversal symmetry forbids spin polarization of the current in single-channel coherent transport between nonmagnetic leads (Bardarson theorem, J. H. Bardarson, J. Phys. A 41, 405203, 2008, https://doi.org/10.1088/1751-8113/41/40/405203), and Onsager reciprocity forbids any magnetoconductance asymmetry $G(M) - G(-M)$ in linear response when one electrode is a ferromagnet of magnetization $M$, for any number of channels. Identify which ingredient (dephasing or leakage channels, electron-electron interaction, electron-vibration coupling, nonlinear bias, interface spinterface effects) produces magnetoconductance asymmetry of the measured size, and prove which are necessary. An answer is a model calculation giving the measured asymmetry and its bias dependence.
-
In linear-response TDDFT with a frequency-independent (adiabatic) exchange-correlation kernel $f_{\mathrm{xc}}$, states of dominant double-excitation character are absent from the spectrum. Construct a frequency-dependent kernel $f_{\mathrm{xc}}(\omega)$ applicable to general molecules at cost comparable to hybrid TDDFT that reproduces the 2 1Ag- states of butadiene, hexatriene and octatetraene and the doubly excited states of the QUEST benchmark (a database of near-exact molecular excitation energies) within $0.2\ \mathrm{eV}$. An answer is such a kernel with benchmarks, or a proof that no kernel in a stated class can do it.
-
For molecules of 10 to 30 non-hydrogen atoms (the larger molecules of the QUEST sets, and gas-phase biological chromophores such as the green fluorescent protein chromophore anion and the protonated retinal Schiff base), determine vertical excitation energies of the lowest singlet and triplet states to 0.05 eV, and identify the lowest-cost method that reaches mean absolute error below 0.05 eV. An answer is theoretical best estimates confirmed by two independent high-order methods plus the method benchmark, cross-checked against gas-phase absorption spectra.
-
Determine the mean electric field projected on a probe bond at the water-air and water-oil interfaces at 300 K, from vibrational Stark shifts of interface-specific probes and from ab initio molecular dynamics, and compare with bulk water. The answer is the field magnitude (reported values range up to about $3 \times 10^{4}\,\mathrm{statvolt}/\mathrm{cm}$) with its spatial profile across the interface.
-
For the excess electron in liquid water at 300 K, determine whether its ground-state density occupies a solvent cavity of radius about 2.5 Angstrom with depleted water density, or overlaps a region of enhanced water density (the non-cavity model of 2010), by reproducing the absorption band (peak near 1.7 eV with its high-energy tail), the radius of gyration (about 2.5 Angstrom), the resonance Raman spectrum and the partial molar volume. An answer is an ab initio simulation with quantum nuclei that reproduces these observables and fixes the structure.
-
For donor-chiral bridge-acceptor molecules in frozen solution, compute the spin polarization of the photogenerated radical pair arising from electron transfer through the chiral bridge, from the molecular Hamiltonian including spin-orbit coupling and electron-vibration coupling, and compare with the measured time-resolved EPR spectra. The answer is the polarization magnitude and its dependence on bridge length and handedness.
-
For $N$ organic emitters under electronic strong coupling with a cavity mode, with reorganization energy $\lambda$ and static energetic disorder $\sigma$, compute the photoreaction quantum yield (for example photoisomerization) after excitation of the lower polariton, accounting for relaxation into the $N-1$ dark states. The answer is whether, and in what range of $\lambda$, $\sigma$ and Rabi splitting, the yield differs from the cavity-free value by more than 10 percent.
-
A quantum transition-state theory valid in the deep-tunneling regime
Partially resolved 40Ring-polymer molecular dynamics transition-state theory (RPMD-TST) is the unique $t\to 0+$ limit of a quantum flux-side time-correlation function and is exact when no recrossing of the dividing surface or its ring-polymer generalizations occurs (Hele and Althorpe, J. Chem. Phys. 2013, https://doi.org/10.1063/1.4792697). Below the crossover temperature $T_{x}=\hbar\omega_{b}/(2\pi)$ ($\omega_{b}=\text{barrier frequency},\ k_{B}=1$) it deviates from exact quantum rates for asymmetric barriers. Derive a rate theory without real-time dynamics whose error vanishes both without recrossing and in the semiclassical instanton limit, or rigorous bounds on the RPMD-TST error versus $T/T_{x}$ and barrier asymmetry, tested on Eckart barriers and H + $\mathrm{H_2}$ type reactions.
-
Given an enantiospecific difference in adsorption rate on perpendicularly magnetized ferromagnetic films, identify the mechanism (transient spin-dependent charge polarization of the molecule during approach followed by exchange interaction with the surface, or another spin-dependent interaction) and compute the size of the rate difference from a microscopic model. An answer is a calculation of spin-dependent adsorption energetics or kinetics that reproduces the measured effect size and its dependence on molecular length.
-
Low-temperature rate enhancement of the OH plus methanol reaction
Partially resolved 38For OH + $\mathrm{CH_3OH}$ in Laval-nozzle flows from about 20 to 200 K, explain the rise of $k(T)$ by about two orders of magnitude below 200 K and its pressure dependence from a calculation combining the hydrogen-bonded pre-reaction complex, deep tunneling through the H-abstraction barrier and collisional stabilization, and determine $k(T)$ in the zero-pressure limit. An answer is a master-equation plus tunneling calculation on an accurate potential that reproduces measured $k(T, P)$.
-
Rules for vibrational mode selectivity in polyatomic reactions
Partially resolved 38For abstraction reactions $X$ + $\mathrm{CH_4}$ and $X$ + $\mathrm{CHD_3}$ ($X = \mathrm{H}, \mathrm{F}, \mathrm{Cl}, \mathrm{O}$) and H + $\mathrm{H_2O}$, predict the vibrational efficacy $\eta_v$ (reactivity gain per unit energy in mode $v$ divided by that per unit translational energy) for each normal mode, and the bond selectivity, from properties of the potential near the transition state. An answer is a criterion tested against full-dimensional quantum scattering and crossed-beam data, including measured cases where C-H stretch excitation is no more effective than translation (Cl + $\mathrm{CHD_3}$) or suppresses reaction (F + $\mathrm{CHD_3}$ at low collision energy).
-
For NO($v_{i}=3$ and $v_{i}=16$) scattering from Au(111) at incidence energies 0.05 to 1 eV, compute the final vibrational distribution $P(v_{f})$ and its dependence on incidence energy and orientation, and identify which treatment of nonadiabatic electron-hole pair excitation (electronic friction, independent-electron surface hopping, or a many-body treatment of the NO- anion state) reproduces the measured multiquantum relaxation. An answer is a first-principles calculation matching $P(v_{f})$ within experimental error for both initial states.
-
For the isolated Fe(II) porphine molecule, determine the adiabatic energy differences among the lowest $S = 0, 1 \text{ and } 2$ states (each at its own optimized geometry, zero-point corrected) to 1 kcal/mol, together with the vertical gaps at a stated common $D4h$ geometry, including the sign of the triplet-quintet gap. An answer is agreement among independent wavefunction methods (coupled cluster with high excitations, DMRG plus perturbation theory, quantum Monte Carlo) extrapolated to the complete basis set limit.
-
Using path-integral simulations on a potential of coupled-cluster quality not fitted to isotope data, compute the $\mathrm{H_2O}$ to $\mathrm{D_2O}$ shifts of the temperature of maximum density (277.13 K versus about 284.3 K), the melting temperature (273.15 K versus about 276.97 K) and the viscosity ratio at 298 K (about 1.23), and decompose each into the competing quantum effects (hydrogen-bond weakening by intermolecular zero-point motion versus strengthening by O-H stretch delocalization). An answer is computed shifts within 1 K and 5 percent of experiment with the decomposition.
-
For the fluoride-induced desilylation of 1-phenyl-2-trimethylsilylacetylene in a Fabry-Perot cavity tuned to the Si-C stretch near $860\ \mathrm{cm}^{-1}$ or the Si-CH3 deformation near $1250\ \mathrm{cm}^{-1}$, determine whether the rate constant changes relative to detuned cavities by more than the combined experimental error, under controlled temperature and identical sample preparation. An answer is a yes or no from multi-laboratory measurements with shared protocols.
-
Nature of the dark $S*$ state in carotenoids
Contested 34In ultrafast transient absorption of carotenoids (beta-carotene, lycopene, spirilloxanthin) in solution and in light-harvesting complexes, the $S*$ signal has been assigned to a vibrationally hot $S1$ ($2\mathrm{Ag}-$) state, a distinct electronic state ($1\mathrm{Bu}-$ or triplet-pair character), a twisted conformer, or ground-state population. Identify the electronic and vibrational character of $S*$, its formation path from $S2$ ($1\mathrm{Bu}+$), and its role in carotenoid-to-chlorophyll energy transfer. An answer is an assignment consistent with transient absorption and 2D spectra and with multireference calculations on polyenes of 9 to 13 conjugated double bonds.
-
For unimolecular decompositions with roaming channels ($\mathrm{H2CO} \to \mathrm{H2} + \mathrm{CO},\ \mathrm{CH3CHO} \to \mathrm{CH4} + \mathrm{CO},\ \mathrm{NO3} \to \mathrm{NO} + \mathrm{O2}$), derive a statistical or dynamical rate theory that predicts the roaming branching fraction and product state distributions versus internal energy from the potential energy surface without full trajectory ensembles, and a criterion on the potential for when roaming exceeds 10 percent of a channel. An answer is such a theory matched to quasiclassical trajectories and state-resolved imaging data on at least three systems.
-
Near-exact correlation energy of benzene in a standard basis
Partially resolved 26For benzene at the reference geometry in the cc-pVDZ basis with frozen $1s$ cores (30 electrons in 108 orbitals), determine the full configuration interaction correlation energy to $0.1\,\mathrm{m}E_h$ ($E_h$ = Hartree unit, about $627.5\,\mathrm{kcal}/\mathrm{mol}$) and establish which near-exact methods (selected configuration interaction, DMRG, FCIQMC, many-body expanded FCI, high-order coupled cluster) converge to it. An answer is a value with a defensible error bar confirmed by at least two independent methods.