This browser is older than PubPhys supports. Every page can be read, but signing in to contribute, voting and signing need Safari 15.4, Chrome or Edge 99, Firefox 97 or newer. Browsers
All problems
74 problems
Starting order drafted by AI. Votes change it. How ranking works
-
Does scale invariance imply conformal invariance in four dimensions?
Partially resolved 49For a unitary, Poincare-invariant 4D QFT with a well-defined stress tensor, determine whether scale invariance implies conformal invariance nonperturbatively. It is proven in 2D (Polchinski 1988), shown to all orders of perturbation theory in 4D (Luty, Polchinski, Rattazzi; Fortin, Grinstein, Stergiou, 2012), and argued nonperturbatively under assumptions (Dymarsky, Komargodski, Schwimmer, Theisen 2013).
-
Is every infinite-distance limit a decompactification or a weak string?
Partially resolved 49Emergent string conjecture (Lee, Lerche, Weigand 2019): in any infinite-distance limit in the moduli space of a d-dimensional quantum gravity theory, the leading tower of states becoming massless in Planck units is either a Kaluza-Klein tower (decompactification) or the excitation tower of a unique weakly coupled, asymptotically tensionless critical string. Prove this from general principles or find a limit whose leading tower is of another kind.
-
For 16 Weyl fermions in 4D (one Standard Model generation with a right-handed neutrino) with interactions preserving Spin(10) or a subgroup with vanishing 't Hooft anomalies, a lattice model may have a gapped phase with no symmetry breaking, no topological order and vanishing bilinear condensates. Determine whether such a phase is reached from the massless phase by a direct continuous transition, which is what a continuum symmetric-mass-generation theory requires.
-
Kinematic Lie algebra of full Yang-Mills theory
Partially resolved 48Identify an infinite-dimensional Lie algebra with structure constants $F$ such that tree-level BCJ numerators of $D$-dimensional Yang-Mills at all multiplicities are nested products of F with the same graph structure as nested color factors $f^{abc}$. In the self-dual sector the algebra is that of area-preserving diffeomorphisms (Monteiro and O'Connell, 2011); an answer is the algebra for the full theory, or a proof that no Lie algebra (as opposed to a Hopf, homotopy or other structure) can do this.
-
Mathematical structure of finite generalized symmetries above two dimensions
Partially resolved 47In $2\mathrm{D}$, finite internal symmetries are fusion categories. In d dimensions finite generalized symmetries are conjectured to be fusion $\left(d-1\right)$-categories, equivalently a $\left(d+1\right)$-dimensional topological field theory (the symmetry TFT) with a gapped boundary. Determine whether every finite generalized symmetry of a d-dimensional QFT arises from a symmetry TFT in this way, and classify the possible structures for $d = 3\ \text{and}\ 4$.
-
Prove high-energy growth bound for gravitational amplitudes from first principles
Partially resolved 47Prove that the $2 \to 2$ amplitude of a consistent quantum gravity theory satisfies $M(s,t)/s^{2} \to 0\ \text{as}\ s \to \infty\ \text{at fixed}\ t < 0$ (so dispersion relations with two subtractions hold), using only unitarity, analyticity, crossing and polynomial or subexponential boundedness, in $D \ge 4$. Haring and Zhiboedov (2022) derived this bound with the extra assumption that scattering at large impact parameter is controlled by known semiclassical physics; justifying or removing that assumption, and handling $D = 4$ infrared divergences, is the open part.
-
For QED with electron mass $m_{e}$ and charge $e$ coupled to gravity, the one-loop light-by-light and gravitational contributions to the forward photon-photon amplitude violate the naive positivity bound unless new states appear at $\Lambda_{\mathrm{new}}\sim(e\,m_{e}\,M_{\mathrm{pl}})^{1/2}$, approximately $2 \times 10^{7}\ \text{to}\ 4 \times 10^{7}\ \mathrm{GeV}$ (reduced or unreduced Planck mass) (Alberte, de Rham, Jaitly, Tolley, Phys. Rev. D 103, 125020, 2021, obtained assuming the t-channel graviton pole can be discarded). Decide whether every consistent UV completion of QED plus gravity has new states below this scale, or whether the allowed Planck-suppressed negativity removes the requirement.
-
For the Adler function $D(Q^2)$ of massless QCD, determine whether the perturbative series in $\alpha_s(Q^2)$ together with OPE power corrections (condensates such as $\langle \alpha_s G^2\rangle/Q^4$) forms a resurgent transseries whose median resummation equals the exact function, with each condensate uniquely defined once the summation prescription is fixed.
-
The He-4 superfluid transition is in the 3D $O(2)$ universality class, with $\alpha = 2 - 3\nu$. The Space Shuttle measurement gives $\alpha = -0.0127(3)$ (Lipa et al. 2003), while the conformal bootstrap gives $\nu = 0.67175(10)$, i.e. $\alpha = -0.01526(30)$ (Chester et al. 2020), in agreement with Monte Carlo; the tension is about 8 standard deviations. Determine whether the discrepancy comes from the experimental analysis (corrections to scaling, finite size, residual gravity), from the identification with the $O(2)$ fixed point, or from an error in theory.
-
Pure $\operatorname{SU}(N)$ Yang-Mills on $R^{3} x S^{1}_L$ with a center-stabilizing double-trace deformation, or $N=1$ super-Yang-Mills with periodic fermions, confines semiclassically at small L via monopole-instantons and bions (Unsal and collaborators, 2007-2008). Determine whether the small-L regime is connected to the $R^4$ theory as $L \to \infty$ without a phase transition, so that the semiclassical mechanism is the 4D mechanism.
-
For $D = 4$ $2\to 2$ graviton scattering with Newton constant $G$, determine nonperturbatively (without assuming a weakly coupled UV completion) the allowed range of the leading higher-derivative coefficients ($R^{3}$ and $R^{4}$ terms) in units of the cutoff, using full nonlinear unitarity. The $D = 10$ analogue was mapped by Guerrieri, Penedones, Vieira (Phys. Rev. Lett. 127, 081601, 2021); in $D = 4$ the infrared divergences must be handled first.
-
String perturbation theory in $g_{s}$ grows like $(2g)!$ at genus $g$ (Shenker 1990), which points to effects of order $\exp(-1/g_{s})$ from D-branes. For the type II superstring in $10\mathrm{D}$ flat space, determine whether the genus expansion of the four-graviton amplitude at fixed kinematics is resurgent, and whether D-instanton sectors give a unique median-resummed result.
-
Exact classical double copy for generic vacuum spacetimes
Partially resolved 44The Kerr-Schild double copy (2014), the Weyl double copy (2018) and the self-dual double copy (Monteiro and O'Connell, 2011) map Kerr-Schild, algebraically special (Petrov types D and N) and self-dual vacuum metrics to exact Maxwell or Yang-Mills solutions. Determine whether an exact, nonperturbative map exists from every Ricci-flat 4D metric, including Petrov type I, to solutions of gauge-theory field equations that reduces to the amplitude double copy order by order, or prove that none exists.
-
Carrollian holography proposes that the 4D asymptotically flat gravitational S-matrix equals correlators of a sourced 3D conformal Carrollian field theory on null infinity, constrained by BMS Ward identities (Donnay, Fiorucci, Herfray, Ruzziconi 2022). Determine whether an intrinsically defined Carrollian theory exists whose correlators reproduce tree and one-loop graviton amplitudes, and how it relates to the celestial CFT.
-
For a weakly coupled 4D effective field theory of a massless scalar coupled to Einstein gravity, with $2\to 2$ amplitude $M(s,t) = 8\pi G s^2/(-t) + c_2 s^2/\Lambda^4 + ...$, determine the lowest value of $c_2$ consistent with unitarity, analyticity, crossing and a UV completion whose amplitude Reggeizes (grows as $s^{2 + \alpha' t}$) above a scale $M_*$. Under this Regge assumption proposals give $c_2 \ge -\operatorname{O}(\Lambda^4/(M_{\mathrm{pl}}^2 M_*^2))$; smeared impact-parameter sum rules in $D = 4$ instead give $c_2 \ge -\operatorname{O}(G \Lambda^4/M^2)\log(M b_{\mathrm{IR}})$, where $M$ is the EFT cutoff and $b_{\mathrm{IR}}$ an infrared impact-parameter cutoff. An answer is the optimal bound in $D = 4$ with its assumptions stated, saying which form is optimal, or an explicit consistent UV completion that violates it.
-
The thermal free energy and anomaly coefficients of the $A_{N-1}$ $(2,0)$ theory scale as $N^{3}$ at large $N$ (Klebanov and Tseytlin 1996 from supergravity). Identify the microscopic degrees of freedom responsible (for example membrane states stretched between triples of M5-branes) and derive the coefficient of $N^{3}$ from them.
-
Distance conjecture (Ooguri and Vafa 2006): along a geodesic of length D in moduli space, measured in Planck units, a tower of states has masses $m \sim \exp(-\lambda D)$. Sharpened version (Etheredge, Heidenreich, Kaya, Qiu, Rudelius 2022): the lightest tower obeys $\lambda \ge 1/\sqrt{d-2}$ in d spacetime dimensions. Prove the bound for all infinite-distance limits of string compactifications, or find a limit with $\lambda < 1/\sqrt{d-2}$.
-
The ABJ-anomalous axial U(1) symmetries of QED and of the Standard Model retain non-invertible rational-angle subgroups (Choi, Lam, Shao 2022; Cordova, Ohmori 2022). Determine the exact selection rules and constraints on observables (neutral pion decay, axion couplings, neutrino masses) that follow from them beyond ordinary anomaly matching.
-
Is four-dimensional RG flow a gradient flow of the a-function?
Partially resolved 41Jack and Osborn (1990) showed perturbatively that the beta functions $\beta^{j}$ of a 4D renormalizable QFT satisfy $d_{i} a\sim = \chi_{ij}\beta^{j} + (d_{i} w_{j} - d_{j} w_{i})\beta^{j}$ for a function $a\sim(g)$ equal to the a-anomaly at fixed points. Determine whether, beyond perturbation theory, $\chi_{ij}$ is positive definite so that $a\sim$ decreases monotonically along every flow (strong a-theorem). The weak version $a_{\mathrm{UV}} > a_{\mathrm{IR}}$ between fixed points is proven (Komargodski and Schwimmer 2011).
-
Is every anomaly-free six-dimensional supergravity realized in string theory?
Partially resolved 41For 6D $N=(1,0)$ supergravity with $T$ tensor multiplets, gauge group $G$ and hypermultiplet content $H$, Green-Schwarz anomaly cancellation restricts $(T, G, H)$. Determine whether every anomaly-free model that meets all known consistency conditions is realized by a string compactification (string universality, Kumar and Taylor 2009), or identify the additional conditions that remove the remainder.
-
Arkani-Hamed, Cao, Dong, Figueiredo and He (Phys. Rev. Lett. 134, 171601, 2025) defined a gauge-invariant, cut-consistent planar (leading-color) Yang-Mills loop integrand using surface kinematics, building on curve-integral formulas for $\operatorname{Tr}\phi^{3}$ theory, with explicit results at one loop for all multiplicities and a simplest two-loop case. Determine whether this integrand, for all multiplicities n and loop orders L in the planar limit, is the canonical form of a positive geometry, and whether a 4D helicity-basis version exists.
-
Find a positive geometry whose canonical form equals tree-level n-graviton amplitudes of Einstein gravity or $N=8$ supergravity in $D = 4$ for all helicity sectors, or the loop integrands of $N=8$ supergravity; or prove that gravity amplitudes cannot be canonical forms in the standard sense.
-
Does the a-anomaly decrease along all six-dimensional RG flows?
Partially resolved 40In unitary 6D QFT, the Euler coefficient a of the trace anomaly is conjectured to satisfy $a_{UV} > a_{IR}$ for every RG flow between CFTs. The 4D dilaton proof (Komargodski and Schwimmer 2011) does not carry over because the relevant six-derivative dilaton coupling is not sign-definite by unitarity. Prove or refute the inequality for general, including non-supersymmetric, flows.
-
In $4\mathrm{D}$ $\mathrm{SU}(N)$ Yang-Mills with topological angle $\theta$, the mixed anomaly between the $Z_{N}$ one-form center symmetry and CP at $\theta = \pi$ (Gaiotto, Kapustin, Komargodski, Seiberg 2017) forbids a trivially gapped confining vacuum. For $N = 2$, determine whether the vacuum at $\theta = \pi$ breaks CP spontaneously (two degenerate vacua and a first-order jump of the topological charge density), is deconfined (including gapped with topological order), or is gapless. Large-N arguments favor CP breaking.
-
The cosmological polytope (Arkani-Hamed, Benincasa, Postnikov, 2017) gives wavefunction coefficients of conformally coupled scalars with polynomial interactions in flat space and FRW backgrounds as canonical forms. Find a positive geometry whose canonical form gives tree-level wavefunction coefficients or in-in correlators of massless minimally coupled scalars or gravitons in de Sitter space.
-
4D $\mathrm{SU}(2)$ gauge theory with two massless Weyl fermions in the adjoint representation (equivalently one adjoint Dirac fermion) has $\mathrm{SU}(2)_{R}$ flavor and $Z_{8}$ discrete chiral symmetry. Determine its deep-infrared phase among the candidates: confinement with $\mathrm{SU}(2)_{R} \to \mathrm{U}(1)$ breaking (a $\mathrm{CP}^{1}$ sigma model), confinement with massless composite fermions, or an interacting CFT (Cordova and Dumitrescu 2018; Anber and Poppitz 2018).
-
Find a region in a space of kinematic data whose canonical form (the unique differential form with logarithmic singularities on the region's boundaries) equals the subleading-color (nonplanar) or the full color-dressed $L$-loop four-point integrand of $N=4$ super-Yang-Mills; momentum twistors are unavailable because there is no planar ordering. Nonplanar integrands with only logarithmic singularities and no poles at infinity have been constructed at low loop order.
-
Lattice spectra of closed flux tubes in $4\mathrm{D}$ $\mathrm{SU}(N)$ Yang-Mills ($N = 3, 5, 6$) are fitted by an effective string of two transverse phonons plus a massive pseudoscalar worldsheet axion coupled to the phonons through a topological term (Dubovsky, Flauger, Gorbenko 2013; Athenodorou, Dubovsky, Luo, Teper 2024). Determine the $N \to \infty$ limits of the axion mass $m_a/\sqrt{\sigma}$ and its coupling, and whether the large-N worldsheet theory is the integrable axionic string constructed by Dubovsky and Gorbenko (2015).
-
Double copy for scattering in anti-de Sitter space
Partially resolved 37Determine whether tree-level boundary correlators of gravitons in $\mathrm{AdS}_{d+1}$ at all multiplicities, and at one loop, follow from gluon correlators by a color-to-kinematics replacement governed by a kinematic algebra that reduces to the flat-space BCJ structure in the flat-space limit. An answer is a general construction with proof, or a counterexample correlator.
-
A conformal manifold is a continuous family of CFTs generated by exactly marginal operators (scaling dimension exactly d along the family). In $d = 3\ \text{or}\ 4$, determine whether a unitary interacting CFT without supersymmetry, at finite $N$, has an exactly marginal operator. Candidates come from holography: families of non-supersymmetric $\mathrm{AdS}_4$ S-fold solutions of type IIB supergravity argued to be perturbatively and nonperturbatively stable (Giambrone et al. 2021; Bobev, Gautason, van Muiden 2023).