This browser is older than PubPhys supports. Every page can be read, but signing in to contribute, voting and signing need Safari 15.4, Chrome or Edge 99, Firefox 97 or newer. Browsers
All problems
99 problems
Starting order drafted by AI. Votes change it. How ranking works
-
For $H = H_S(t) + H_B + H_I$ with the norm of $H_I$ comparable to the system energy scale, find definitions of internal energy $U$, work $W$ and heat $Q$ of the system that satisfy the first law, a second law (Clausius inequality or nonnegative entropy production), reduce to weak-coupling results, and are measurable by local operations; or prove that no definition satisfies all of these.
-
For $1+1D$ brickwork circuits of Haar-random two-qudit gates (local dimension q) with projective measurements at rate p, determine the critical exponents at $p_c$ (correlation-length exponent nu, entanglement scaling and surface exponents) and identify the field theory, for finite q and as q goes to $\infty$ where the transition maps to classical percolation. Qubit numerics give $\nu \sim 1.2-1.3$ (approximate) with other exponents distinct from percolation (Zabalo et al. 2020).
-
For a free particle of spin 0 or 1/2 with initial wave packet $\psi_0$ and an ideal detector surface at distance $L$, determine the distribution of detection times, comparing the quantum flux $J(L,t)$, the Kijowski distribution, Bohmian predictions including the spin term of the Pauli current (Das and Durr, Scientific Reports 2019), and absorbing-boundary models. An answer is a derivation from detector models that singles one out, or an experiment resolving their differences.
-
A pilot-wave theory for interacting quantum fields without preferred foliation
Partially resolved 36Bohmian mechanics for entangled particles and its field-theory extensions (Bell-type quantum field theories with stochastic particle creation) use a preferred spacelike foliation; Durr, Goldstein, Norsen, Struyve and Zanghi (Proc. R. Soc. A 2014) showed that for fixed particle number the foliation can be generated covariantly from the wave function. Determine whether a hidden-variable theory for an interacting relativistic QFT (e.g. QED) exists whose only extra spacetime structure is fixed covariantly by the wave function, with well-defined beables through particle creation and annihilation, reproducing all quantum predictions; or prove that such a theory needs structure not determined by the dynamics.
-
The stabilizer rank $\chi(\psi)$ is the least number of stabilizer states whose linear combination equals $\psi$. Prove $\chi(\left|T\right>^{\otimes n}) \ge 2^{c n}$ for some constant $c > 0$, where $\left|T\right> = (\left|0\right> + e^{i \pi/4} \left|1\right>)/\sqrt{2}$. Known upper bounds are of order $2^{0.4 n}$ (approximate exponent) and known lower bounds are only polynomial in n.
-
$Q(N) = \lim_{n \to \infty} (1/n) \max_\rho I_c(\rho, N^{(\otimes\ n)})$, with $I_c$ the coherent information. Is there an algorithm that, given a channel N with rational Kraus operators and $\epsilon > 0$, outputs $Q(N)$ to within $\epsilon$, or that decides whether $Q(N) > 0$? Cubitt et al. (Nat. Commun. 6, 7739, 2015, arXiv:1408.5115) showed that for every n there are channels with zero n-use coherent information and positive capacity.
-
For a clock of rest mass m with internal Hamiltonian $H_{\mathrm{clock}}$ whose center of mass is in a coherent superposition of momenta, the mass-energy coupling $H = \sqrt{p^{2} c^{2} + (m c^{2} + H_{\mathrm{clock}})^{2}}$ gives a proper-time distribution that differs from that of the corresponding classical mixture of momenta by a coherence-dependent term (Smith and Ahmadi, Nature Communications 2020). Determine whether atomic or ion clocks can resolve this quantum contribution, the momentum separation and fractional frequency resolution required, and measure it.
-
Minimal time to cool a quantum system near absolute zero
Partially resolved 36For a finite system cooled within time t by a refrigerator of bounded size and Hamiltonian norm, determine the optimal scaling of the final temperature T(t) or ground-state infidelity with t and with resource measures (energy, bath dimension, control complexity), improving the lower bound of Masanes and Oppenheim (Nature Communications 2017) and the Landauer-versus-Nernst cost analysis (Taranto et al., 2023).
-
For heat engines with a $d$-level working medium coupled to baths at $T_h > T_c$, compare the maximal power $P$ at fixed efficiency $\eta$ (or the efficiency at maximum power) of coherent quantum cycles with the best stochastic classical engine having the same level structure, bath couplings and control constraints. Determine whether $P_{quantum} > P_{classical}$ strictly, and identify the resource responsible.
-
For random geometrically local circuits on $n$ qubits (Haar two-qubit gates, brickwork, depth $D$) with single-qubit amplitude damping of strength $\gamma > 0$ after each gate and no mid-circuit measurement, is there a $\operatorname{poly}(n, 1/\delta)$ classical algorithm that samples the output to total-variation error $\delta$ for all $D \ge D_0(\gamma)$, with $D_0$ independent of $n$? Local expectation values are classically computable because this noise limits the effective depth to $O(\log n)$ (Mele et al. 2024), but outputs do not anticoncentrate (Fefferman et al. 2024), so existing sampling arguments fail; for unital depolarizing noise of strength $p$, a 2026 preprint proves efficient sampling for $D \ge \Omega(p^{-1} \log p^{-1})$ in any geometrically local circuit (arXiv:2610.00548).
-
For a quantum system with a classically chaotic limit, positive Lyapunov exponents $\lambda_i$, and weak Markovian coupling to an environment with momentum-diffusion constant $D$, Zurek and Paz (PRL 1994) conjectured that after a transient the von Neumann entropy $S$ of the reduced state grows as $dS/dt = \text{sum of positive } \lambda_i$, independent of $D$ over a wide range. Determine the range of $D$, effective Planck constant $\hbar_{\mathrm{eff}}$ and time for which this holds, and its corrections, in standard models (kicked rotor, kicked top); a related coupling-independent Lyapunov decay of the Loschmidt echo was found by Jalabert and Pastawski (PRL 2001).
-
Determine whether every behavior in the almost-quantum set (level 1+AB of the Navascues-Pironio-Acin hierarchy, Navascues et al., Nature Communications 2015) satisfies information causality, in its original form and its generalized correlated-input form, for any number of copies and any wiring. An answer is a proof or an explicit almost-quantum box with a violating protocol.
-
For the qubit depolarizing channel $D_p(\rho) = (1 - p) \rho + (p/3)(X \rho X + Y \rho Y + Z \rho Z)$, find $p*$ with quantum capacity $Q(D_p) > 0$ if and only if $p < p*$. Known: $Q = 0$ for $p \ge 1/4$; the hashing bound is positive up to $p \sim 0.1893$, and degenerate codes push positivity above 0.19 (DiVincenzo, Shor and Smolin 1998; Smith and Smolin 2007), with further small improvements since. More generally, compute $Q(D_p)$ for any $0 < p < 1/4$.
-
Quantum reference frame changes for general and imperfect frames
Partially resolved 34Construct transformations between quantum reference frames for arbitrary symmetry groups (including non-Abelian, e.g. SU(2) rotations) and non-ideal frames (finite-dimensional, with non-orthogonal orientation states), and prove equivalence or a precise relation between the perspective-neutral (constraint-based), operational and perspectival approaches. An answer is one framework with proofs that each existing one is a special case, or a stated inequivalence.
-
Which process matrices are physically realizable?
Partially resolved 34Wechs, Branciard and Oreshkov (2023) showed that every unitarily extendible tripartite process has a realization on time-delocalized subsystems. Determine (a) whether every unitarily extendible process with $N \ge 4$ parties has such a realization, and (b) whether processes with no unitary extension (no purification), such as the Oreshkov-Costa-Brukner bipartite process, admit any realization within standard quantum theory.
-
Explicit Bell game separating commuting-operator and tensor-product quantum models
Partially resolved 34$\mathrm{MIP}* = \mathrm{RE}$ (Ji, Natarajan, Vidick, Wright, Yuen, arXiv:2001.04383) implies a nonlocal game $G$ with finite inputs and outputs whose commuting-operator value $w_{qc}(G)$ exceeds its tensor-product value $w_{q}(G)$, resolving Tsirelson's problem negatively. Construct an explicit $G$, state its input size and gap, and certify $w_{qc}(G) > w_{q}(G)$.
-
In elliptically polarized strong-field ionization of atomic hydrogen or helium, extract the tunneling delay $\tau_T$ from the photoelectron momentum offset angle after subtracting the Coulomb deflection computed from the full time-dependent Schrodinger equation, and decide whether $\tau_T = 0$ within resolution. A 2019 hydrogen experiment (Sainadh et al., Nature) reported $\tau_{T}$ below about $1.8 \times 10^{-18}\,\mathrm{s}$.
-
Does there exist a family of $O(1)$-local Hamiltonians on $n$ qubits and a constant $\epsilon > 0$ such that every state with energy below $E_{0} + \epsilon m$ fails to be classically sampleable in the sense of Gharibian and Le Gall (2022), i.e. no $\operatorname{poly}(n)$ classical algorithm samples its computational-basis distribution with the required query access?
-
For every integer $d \ge 2$, do there exist $d^{2}$ unit vectors $\psi_j$ in $C^d$ with $\mid\langle\psi_j\mid\psi_k\rangle\mid^{2} = 1/(d+1)$ for all $j != k$? Zauner's conjecture further asserts a Weyl-Heisenberg covariant solution whose fiducial vector is fixed by an order-3 Clifford unitary. Exact solutions are known in all $d$ up to about 50 and in some much larger $d$, numerical ones in all d up to about 150 (figures approximate).
-
Given $H = \sum_i h_i$ with pairwise commuting k-local projectors $h_i$ on qudits of dimension $q$, decide whether the ground energy is 0 or at least $1/\operatorname{poly}(n)$. Is this in NP for all constant k and q? Known in NP: 2-local (Bravyi and Vyalyi 2003), some 3-local cases (Aharonov and Eldar 2011), $2\mathrm{D}$ qubits (Schuch 2011), $2\mathrm{D}$ qutrits and factorized terms of any dimension (Irani and Jiang, arXiv:2309.04910).
-
For $N$ identical cells with $H_{0}=\sum_i h_i$, a charging Hamiltonian $V(t)$ that is a sum of at most $k$-body terms of bounded norm, and charging power $P=(E(\tau)-E(0))/\tau$, define the advantage $\Gamma=P_{\mathrm{collective}}/P_{\mathrm{parallel}}$. Gyhm, Safranek and Rosa (PRL 2022) proved that $\Gamma$ cannot grow extensively in $N$ without global operations; determine the maximal scaling of $\Gamma$ with N and k under stated constraints (bounded energy per cell, bounded interaction strength, geometric locality), and whether any physical constraint set allows $\Gamma$ to grow with $N$ at fixed $k$.
-
For cold atoms (e.g. 87Rb) tunneling through an optical barrier with an internal-state Larmor clock, measure the transmitted-atom Larmor times $\tau_y$ and $\tau_z$ versus barrier width $L$ in the opaque regime $\kappa L >> 1$, $\kappa = \sqrt{2 m (V_0 - E)} / \hbar$, and determine whether they saturate with $L$ as the Hartman effect predicts for the phase delay.
-
Can a consistent theory beyond quantum mechanics have three-path interference?
Partially resolved 28Within generalized probabilistic theories (GPTs), determine whether a theory with nonzero third-order interference $I_3$ exists that satisfies causality, tomographic locality and a consistent composition rule with entangled states. Barnum, Lee, Scandolo and Selby (Entropy 2017, arXiv:1704.05106) showed that causality, purity preservation, pure sharpness and purification together exclude higher-order interference; the task is to find which postulates can be dropped.
-
Perarnau-Llobet et al. (PRL 2017) proved that no POVM-based work distribution $P(W)$ both reproduces two-point-measurement statistics for states diagonal in energy and gives $\langle W\rangle = \operatorname{Tr}[\rho (U^{\mathrm{dag}} H_1 U - H_0)]$ for all states. Determine which relaxed object (a quasiprobability such as Kirkwood-Dirac or Margenau-Hill, or a disturbing measurement scheme) is the operationally correct description of work for coherent states, judged by fluctuation theorems and experimental accessibility.
-
For 1D free fermions with particle-number conservation under random projective (or continuous weak) measurements of local occupation numbers at rate $\gamma$, decide whether the half-chain entanglement $S(L) \sim c(\gamma) \log L$ persists as $L$ goes to $\infty$ for $\gamma$ below some $\gamma_{c}$, or whether $S$ saturates (area law) for all $\gamma > 0$ beyond a length $\ell(\gamma) \sim \exp(C/\gamma)$. The nonlinear sigma model analysis of Poboiko, Popperl, Gornyi and Mirlin (Phys. Rev. X 13, 041046, 2023) predicts the latter.
-
In an ontological model each pure state psi of a d-dimensional system is a probability measure $\mu_{\psi}$ on an ontic space; the classical overlap $\omega_C(\psi,\phi)$ = integral of $\min(\mu_{\psi},\mu_{\phi})$ is compared with the quantum overlap $\omega_Q=1-\sqrt{1-\mid\langle\psi\mid\phi\rangle\mid^2}$. Psi-epistemic models with $\omega_C>0$ for all non-orthogonal pairs exist in every finite d (Lewis, Jennings, Barrett, Rudolph, PRL 2012), the Pusey-Barrett-Rudolph theorem (Nature Physics 2012) excludes them under preparation independence, and Leifer (PRL 2014) proved that $\omega_C/\omega_Q$ decays exponentially in d for certain state families when $4\ \mathrm{divides}\ d$. Determine the optimal achievable ratio as a function of d: a construction matching the upper bound, or a sharper bound.
-
PPT-squared conjecture: is composing two PPT channels entanglement breaking
Partially resolved 26For all quantum channels $\Phi_1, \Phi_2$ on d x d matrices whose Choi matrices have positive partial transpose, is $\Phi_2$ composed with $\Phi_1$ entanglement breaking? Proved for $d \le 3$ (2018-2019) and in an asymptotic form under repeated composition; open for $d \ge 4$.
-
For photonic quantum-switch experiments (operations applied at two distinct times on a time-delocalized subsystem), determine whether the process is causally nonseparable relative to spacetime-localized events, or is a causally ordered circuit on time-delocalized subsystems (Oreshkov, Quantum 2019). An answer is an agreed operational definition of an event and a classification of existing experiments under it.
-
Is the $I3322$ quantum maximum reached in finite dimension?
Partially resolved 26For the Collins-Gisin $I3322$ Bell functional (two parties, three two-outcome measurements each), determine whether the supremum over tensor-product quantum strategies, approximately 0.25087538 (Pal and Vertesi, PRA 2010), is attained by any finite-dimensional strategy, and how the local dimension needed to come within $\epsilon$ of it grows. The residual task is verification of the 2026 claims: non-attainment in finite dimension, attainment by an infinite-dimensional strategy on $\ell^{2}(Z) x \ell^{2}(Z)$, and required dimension of order $\log(1/\epsilon)$.
-
Let $v_c^{\mathrm{POVM}}$ be the critical visibility of $\rho_W(v)$ under arbitrary local POVMs. Known: $\rho_W(v)$ is local for all POVMs when $v \le 1/2$ (Zhang and Chitambar, arXiv:2309.09960) and for projective measurements when $v \le 0.6875$. Determine whether $v_c^{\mathrm{POVM}}$ equals the projective threshold $v_c$.