This browser is older than PubPhys supports. Every page can be read, but signing in to contribute, voting and signing need Safari 15.4, Chrome or Edge 99, Firefox 97 or newer. Browsers
All problems
64 problems
Starting order drafted by AI. Votes change it. How ranking works
-
Is the generic Kerr Cauchy horizon a weak null singularity?
Partially resolved 48For generic vacuum perturbations of subextremal Kerr ($0 < a < M$), Dafermos and Luk (2025) proved $C^0$ stability of the Cauchy horizon. Prove that for generic data the metric admits no continuous extension with Christoffel symbols in $L^2_{\mathrm{loc}}$ across the Cauchy horizon (the Christodoulou-Chrusciel formulation), i.e. that a weak null singularity forms. An answer is a proof of generic inextendibility or a counterexample.
-
Prove the restricted quantum focusing conjecture for semiclassical gravity
Partially resolved 47Define the generalized entropy $S_{\mathrm{gen}} = A c^3/(4 G \hbar) + S_{\mathrm{out}}$ of a codimension-2 surface (entropy in units of $k_{\mathrm{B}}$, $S_{\mathrm{out}}$ the entropy of fields outside it) and the quantum expansion $\Theta$ as its variation per unit transverse area along a null congruence with affine parameter $\lambda$. The original quantum focusing conjecture dTheta/dlambda <= 0 (Bousso, Fisher, Leichenauer, Wall 2015) has explicit counterexamples in two-dimensional dilaton gravity coupled to quantum fields (2025); the restricted version requires dTheta/dlambda <= 0 only where $\Theta = 0$ (Shahbazi-Moghaddam 2022). Prove the restricted conjecture for interacting quantum fields coupled to semiclassical gravity in spacetime dimension $d > 2$, or construct a violation.
-
In AdS/CFT with a single-sided black hole of entropy S, determine whether operators acting on modes behind the horizon can be represented by fixed linear operators on the boundary Hilbert space for all typical states, or whether the representation must depend on the state (Papadodimas-Raju construction). Answer yes (state dependence is necessary) or no, with a proof or an explicit state-independent construction, and state whether non-isometric code models of the interior evade the requirement.
-
Solve the semiclassical Einstein equations with the renormalized $\langle T_{ab}\rangle$ of $N_{f}$ free massless fields (all angular momenta, not only s-waves) for a black hole formed by collapse, from formation to $M \sim m_{P}$, with $N_{f}$ large to suppress fluctuations. Determine the evolution of the apparent and event horizons, whether an inner apparent horizon forms and where the trapped region closes, and the deviation of $\mathrm{d}M/\mathrm{d}t$ from the adiabatic rate. An answer is a numerical or analytic spacetime with controlled errors.
-
Is decoding interior partners from Hawking radiation exponentially hard?
Partially resolved 46Given the radiation of a black hole of entropy $S$, is distilling the qubit entangled with a given late Hawking mode (the Harlow-Hayden task) quantum-computationally hard, requiring time $\exp(\Omega(S))$ for every quantum algorithm, for realistic black hole dynamics instead of idealized random unitaries? An answer is a reduction to a standard hardness assumption, an unconditional bound, or an efficient algorithm.
-
For the EPRL-FK spin foam amplitude on a fixed 4D triangulation, the large-spin limit of each vertex amplitude gives the Regge action (the discrete Einstein-Hilbert action on a triangulation), but the spin sum appears dominated by configurations with vanishing deficit angles, the flatness problem (Hellmann and Kaminski 2013). Determine whether, under refinement or coarse-graining at fixed Barbero-Immirzi parameter $\gamma$, the amplitude is dominated by discrete geometries approximating curved solutions of Einstein's equations. An answer is an asymptotic or numerical demonstration in a refinement limit, or a proof of dominance by flat configurations.
-
Is the string to black hole transition smooth for Schwarzschild black holes?
Partially resolved 45In weakly coupled string theory in 4D asymptotically flat space, follow a Schwarzschild black hole as the string coupling $g_s$ decreases at fixed entropy until $r_s \sim l_s$. Determine whether the black hole connects continuously to a self-gravitating highly excited string state (Horowitz-Polchinski solution), with the entropy matched including $O(1)$ factors. An answer is a controlled computation of the free energy across $r_s \sim l_s$, or a proof of a phase transition.
-
In scalar-Gauss-Bonnet theories with $f(\phi)$ allowing spontaneous scalarization (Doneva and Yazadjiev 2018; Silva et al. 2018), determine from binary inspirals (dipole radiation entering at $-1$ post-Newtonian order) and ringdowns whether scalarized black holes exist, by constraining the coupling length $\sqrt{\alpha}$ relative to observed black hole masses. An answer is a detection of dipole radiation or a bound on $\sqrt{\alpha}$ that excludes scalarization for all observed masses.
-
In 4D causal dynamical triangulations the phase diagram in bare couplings $(\kappa_{0}, \Delta)$ contains a phase C with de Sitter-like large-scale geometry; transitions bordering phase C, including the one to the bifurcation phase, show second- or higher-order signatures, while the A-C transition is first order (Ambjorn, Jordan, Jurkiewicz, Loll 2012 and later work). Determine whether a second-order critical point exists at which the lattice spacing goes to zero while large-scale geometry approaches a classical 4D solution with finite renormalized Newton constant, and compute its critical exponents. An answer is a finite-size scaling analysis at volumes large enough to fix order and exponents, with a continuum observable that converges.
-
The nonlinear (Christodoulou) memory produces a permanent step in the strain, mainly in the $(\ell,m) = (2,0)$ mode, with amplitude a small fraction of the peak oscillatory strain for comparable-mass binaries. Determine whether stacking binary black hole events in ground detectors, or single loud events in LISA, detects the memory at more than $3\sigma$ with the GR amplitude; Lasky et al. (2016) estimated 35 to 90 GW150914-like events for Advanced LIGO. An answer is a detection with the measured amplitude relative to the GR prediction, or an upper limit inconsistent with it.
-
In a quasi-one-dimensional atomic BEC with a stationary sonic horizon (step potential or waterfall configuration), measure the equal-time density-density correlation G2(x, x') and extract the Hawking-partner correlation band across the horizon and its Fourier spectrum. An answer is an observation by a group other than the Technion group at high statistical significance of a stationary correlation band whose spectrum matches $T_{H}=\hbar \kappa/(2\pi)$ for the measured $\kappa$, with stimulated contributions (initial thermal phonons, black-hole-laser amplification, Bogoliubov-Cherenkov emission from obstacles) quantitatively excluded.
-
Is Kerr the only smooth stationary vacuum black hole?
Partially resolved 44Prove that every smooth ($C^{\infty}$, not assumed real-analytic), asymptotically flat, stationary vacuum $3+1$ black hole exterior with a connected non-degenerate horizon is isometric to a Kerr exterior with $\mid a \mid < M$. Known results: true under analyticity (Hawking, Carter, Robinson), under conditions on the bifurcate sphere (Ionescu and Klainerman 2009), and for small perturbations of Kerr (Alexakis, Ionescu, Klainerman 2010). An answer is a proof or a smooth non-Kerr counterexample.
-
For Reissner-Nordstrom-de Sitter black holes near extremality, linear scalar perturbations admit $H^{1}_{\mathrm{loc}}$ extensions across the Cauchy horizon when $\beta=\alpha/\kappa_{-}>1/2$, with $\alpha$ the quasinormal-mode spectral gap and $\kappa_{-}$ the Cauchy horizon surface gravity (Cardoso et al. 2018). Determine whether the Christodoulou formulation of strong cosmic censorship holds when (i) initial data of physically appropriate low regularity and (ii) quantum fields in Hadamard states are included. Answer yes or no for each, with the parameter range.
-
Consider objects of mass $\sim m_{P}$ with $N\sim \exp(S_{\mathrm{initial}})$ internal states, where $S_{\mathrm{initial}}$ can be arbitrarily large. Determine whether an effective field theory containing such remnants avoids pair-production rates and thermal contributions proportional to $N$, for example through form factors that suppress their couplings, while remaining unitary and local. Answer yes with a consistent model, or no with a general argument.
-
For the two-sided AdS-Schwarzschild black hole, the maximal-volume slice anchored at boundary time t grows as $V(t)\ \text{proportional to}\ t$ up to times of order $\exp(S)$. Determine whether a precisely defined boundary quantity (circuit complexity, Krylov complexity, or another) of the thermofield-double state equals $V/(G \ell_{\mathrm{AdS}})$ up to normalization, including saturation at $t \sim \exp(S)$ and the switchback response to perturbations. An answer is a boundary definition with proven matching properties or a demonstration that no unique quantity is singled out.
-
For Kerr-AdS with reflecting boundary conditions at conformal infinity, linear waves decay only logarithmically in time (Holzegel and Smulevici), and superradiant instabilities occur when $\Omega_{H}\ell > 1$, with $\Omega_{H}$ the horizon angular velocity and l the AdS radius. Determine whether small perturbations of Kerr-AdS with $\Omega_{H}\ell < 1$ remain small for all time or develop turbulent cascades, and identify the end state when $\Omega_{H}\ell > 1$. An answer is a theorem or convergent numerical evidence.
-
In numerical-relativity waveforms and in data, determine the earliest time $t_0$ after the strain peak at which $h(t)$ is described within numerical error by a finite sum of linear Kerr quasinormal modes with constant amplitudes, and whether overtones fitted before $t_0$ are physical or absorb nonlinear and transient content. An answer is a quantitative criterion for $t_0$, in units of $G M_f/c^{3}$, as a function of mass ratio and spins, validated on simulations.
-
One-loop Euclidean gravity gives $S = A c^{3}/(4 G \hbar) + C \ln(A/\ell_{P}^{2}) + ...$, with $C$ fixed by the massless spectrum and the ensemble; Sen (2012) computed $C$ for Schwarzschild and Kerr in various dimensions. Reproduce $C$ from a microscopic count for a non-extremal black hole in some UV-complete theory. An answer is a microscopic derivation of $C$ agreeing with the macroscopic value.
-
For phonon modes $b_u$ (outgoing Hawking mode in the subsonic region) and $b_d$ (partner mode in the supersonic region) at frequency $\omega$, the Gaussian state is non-separable if $\left|\langle b_u b_d\rangle\right|^2 > n_u n_d$, with $n_u, n_d$ the mode occupations. Determine whether this inequality holds in a BEC analog black hole, by a measurement that either accesses phase as well as density quadratures or validates the Gaussian and stationarity assumptions independently, and identify the frequency range in which entanglement survives initial thermal occupation. An answer is a certified yes or no with the frequency window.
-
Linear fields on extremal Kerr ($a=M$) show the Aretakis instability (non-decay and growth of transversal derivatives along the horizon) and azimuthal instabilities (Gajic 2023). Determine the nonlinear evolution of vacuum data near extremal Kerr: whether solutions settle to a subextremal or extremal Kerr exterior, whether horizon instabilities produce singular behavior, and the codimension of the set of data that remain extremal. An answer is a theorem describing the asymptotic state.
-
Are quadratic quasinormal modes present in observed ringdowns?
Partially resolved 39Second-order perturbation theory predicts a mode at frequency $2\omega_{220}$ in the $(4,4)$ harmonic with amplitude ratio $A_{220x220}/(A_{220})^2$ fixed by the remnant spin (measured in simulations, 2023). Determine whether such quadratic modes are detected in gravitational-wave data at $5\sigma$ or more, confirmed by independent pipelines, and whether the amplitude ratio matches the general-relativity value. An answer is a detection with a measured ratio, or an upper limit inconsistent with the prediction.
-
Projectable Horava gravity in $3+1$ dimensions is perturbatively renormalizable (Barvinsky, Blas, Herrero-Valea, Sibiryakov, Steinwachs 2016) and has asymptotically free UV fixed points with RG trajectories reaching the region where the kinetic coupling $\lambda$ takes its general-relativity value 1, with the gravitational coupling going to zero at both ends (Barvinsky, Kurov, Sibiryakov 2023). The theory also contains an extra scalar graviton that is unstable or strongly coupled near $\lambda = 1$. Determine whether the IR theory along these trajectories passes solar-system and gravitational-wave tests, including bounds on Lorentz violation in gravity. An answer is the IR effective theory including the scalar sector, compared with those bounds.
-
For constrained systems in which every candidate clock function T has turning points along classical orbits (the global problem of time, for example chaotic Bianchi IX minisuperspace), determine whether a consistent unitary relational dynamics exists, by patching local clocks or otherwise, and whether its predictions are independent of the patching. An answer is a construction with proven clock-change consistency in a chaotic model, or a no-go theorem.
-
Loop quantum gravity and related models propose a quantum transition from black hole to white hole (Haggard and Rovelli 2014) with a lifetime scaling between $M^{2}$ and $M^{3}$ in Planck units. Compute the transition amplitude from a well-defined quantum gravity path integral and determine whether this channel dominates over Hawking evaporation. Answer yes or no, with the lifetime as a function of $M$.
-
Does a black hole second law hold beyond effective field theory?
Partially resolved 36Davies and Reall (2023) built a dynamical entropy, order by order in derivatives, that obeys a second law non-perturbatively in the perturbation amplitude for any gravitational effective field theory while the black hole stays within the effective-theory regime. Determine whether a second law holds for a higher-curvature theory taken as exact, such as Einstein-Gauss-Bonnet in $D > 4$ or a UV-complete string effective action, outside the effective-theory regime, and whether the dynamical entropy is unique up to stated ambiguities. An answer is a proof or an explicit violating solution.
-
Are the different relational descriptions of quantum time equivalent?
Partially resolved 35For a constrained quantum system with Hamiltonian constraint $H\mid\psi> = 0$, compare (i) the Page-Wootters conditional-state formalism, (ii) relational Dirac observables on the physical Hilbert space, and (iii) reduced quantization deparametrized with respect to a chosen clock. Determine conditions under which they give unitarily equivalent predictions, including clocks with degenerate or bounded spectra and clocks that interact with the rest of the system. An answer is an equivalence theorem with explicit conditions or a counterexample.
-
For the vacuum Einstein equations on asymptotically $R^{3,1} x S^1$ with data near a uniform black string above the Gregory-Laflamme threshold (the length above which the string is unstable), numerical evolution shows a self-similar cascade of thinning necks reaching zero radius in finite asymptotic time (Lehner and Pretorius 2010); thin black rings in asymptotically flat 5D behave similarly (Figueras, Kunesch, Tunyasuvunakool 2016). Prove that an open set of such data yields a maximal development with incomplete future null infinity, a generic violation of weak cosmic censorship in $D = 5$, or prove that the cascade halts.
-
Can soft gravitational charges carry the information of an evaporating black hole?
Partially resolved 34Supertranslation and superrotation (BMS) charges and the associated soft graviton modes at the horizon and null infinity were proposed as information carriers (Hawking, Perry, Strominger 2016). Count the independent soft-hair states accessible to a Schwarzschild black hole of mass M in the semiclassical regime and determine whether they can purify the Hawking radiation, i.e. carry of order $A c^{3}/(4 G \hbar)$ units of entropy correlated with the hard quanta. Answer yes or no with the entropy count.
-
In a 2D BEC or a quantum fluid of light with an effective scale factor $a(t)$ set by expansion or an interaction ramp, phonons at momenta $k$ and $-k$ acquire occupation $n_k$ and anomalous correlation $c_k = \langle b_k b_{-k}\rangle$. Determine whether $\mid c_k\mid > n_k$ (non-separability for the symmetric two-mode state) holds after accounting for the initial thermal occupation, and whether $n_k$ matches the vacuum Bogoliubov coefficient $\mid\beta_k\mid^2$ for the imposed $a(t)$. An answer is a measurement establishing or excluding the inequality with stated confidence and a measured initial temperature.
-
In the Born-Oppenheimer expansion of the Wheeler-DeWitt equation in powers of $1/m_P^{2}$ (Kiefer and Singh 1991), the matter wave function obeys a Schrodinger equation with time defined by the gravitational WKB phase, plus $O(1/m_P^{2})$ correction terms that are not Hermitian with respect to the naive inner product. Determine whether an inner product and choice of clock exist that make the corrected evolution unitary order by order. An answer is a construction or a proof that the $O(1/m_P^{2})$ unitarity violation is physical.